Best beer brewing kits

Six complete starter kits, compared on what’s in the box, how much beer each makes and what you still have to buy.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

On this page
  1. The picks
  2. Scores
  3. Northern Brewer 5 gal
  4. Craft A Brew 5 gal
  5. BrewDemon 2 gal
  6. Mr. Beer 4 gal
  7. Craft A Brew 1 gal
  8. Northern Brewer 1 gal
  9. Compare the kits
  10. What’s in the box
  11. What else to buy
  12. How much beer
  13. Time to first beer
  14. Is it legal?
  15. Kinds of kit
  16. How to choose
  17. Questions
  18. How we pick

Quick answer

For most new brewers, get the Northern Brewer Brew Share Enjoy kit. It’s the only pick with a brew kettle, a hydrometer and a thermometer in the box, and it makes 5 gallons. For a 30-minute brew day with bottles included, get the Mr. Beer 4 gallon kit.

Northern Brewer Brew Share Enjoy kit with two white buckets, a stainless brew kettle, a red bottle capper and the starter kit box
Best for most new brewers$164.99 at AmazonPrice as of Nov 16, 2026, 5:34 AM EST
Check it on Amazon

Six beer kits for your first batch

All six were new and in stock at our 2:36 AM check on Oct 22, sold by the maker or Amazon.com. Each comes with equipment and a first recipe.

Craft A Brew Everyday 5 gallon kit with two white buckets, a recipe kit box, a black bottle capper, caps, tubing and a guide book
Best for 5 gallons in your own pot

Craft A Brew Everyday 5 gallon

$129.00 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 16, 2026, 5:34 AM EST · low stock then
Details ↓
Mr. Beer 4 gallon kit with a brown fermenter keg, a row of amber plastic bottles, two refill cans and the kit box
Best for a 30-minute brew day

Mr. Beer 4 gallon

$59.99 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 16, 2026, 5:34 AM EST · low stock then
Details ↓
Northern Brewer 1 gallon kit with a glass fermenter of beer, a red bottle capper, a bottle and the kit box
Best for a small batch with no siphon

Northern Brewer Siphonless 1 gallon

$86.66 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 16, 2026, 5:34 AM EST
Details ↓

How the six kits score

One formula for all six: what each kit includes for cleaning, moving beer, bottling and measuring.

Northern Brewer 5 gal9.5Craft A Brew 5 gal9.5BrewDemon 2 gal9.5Mr. Beer 4 gal9.0Craft A Brew 1 gal8.0Northern Brewer 1 gal7.3010Northern Brewer 5 gal9.5Craft A Brew 5 gal9.5BrewDemon 2 gal9.5Mr. Beer 4 gal9.0Craft A Brew 1 gal8.0Northern Brewer 1 gal7.3
Plain Buy Guides spec score out of 10, from four checks on each maker’s list of what’s included. It’s our arithmetic, not a customer rating.

Three kits tie at 9.5, each for a different reason. The two 5-gallon kits include a hydrometer and thermometer but no bottles. The BrewDemon includes bottles but only a stick-on temperature gauge.

The 1-gallon kits score lower because each leaves out more of the bottling or testing gear. They’re still complete enough to brew a first batch.

The six kits in detail

Best for most new brewers

Northern Brewer Brew Share Enjoy

Chinook IPA, 5 gallon
$164.99
Check it on Amazon
in stock · price as of Nov 16, 2026, 5:34 AM EST
9.5Spec scoreHow it’s scored
Cleaning10
Transfer10
Bottling8
Measuring10

Pros

  • Only pick with a brew kettle in the box
  • Hydrometer, test jar and lab thermometer
  • Siphonless fermenter plus a bottling bucket
  • Capper and caps included
  • Free Homebrewing 101 course

Cons

  • Bottles not included
  • Needs room for two 6.5 gallon buckets
  • 5 gallons is a big first batch
  • Chinook IPA is a hoppy first beer
5 gal batch5 gal kettle6.5 gal fermenterHydrometerCapperSku 7622P

Buy it if

You want one box that covers the whole job, kettle included, and you have space for two buckets and about 50 bottles.

Skip it if

You’d rather start small on a kitchen counter. The Craft A Brew 1 gallon makes 10 to 12 bottles.

Brew Share Enjoy is Northern Brewer’s main 5-gallon starter kit. This listing comes with the Chinook IPA recipe. It was new, sold by Northern Brewer and in stock at our 2:36 AM check on Oct 22.

It’s our pick for most new brewers because nothing else here includes the pot. The kit has a 5 gallon stainless steel brew kettle and a 21 in. stainless spoon. Every other pick asks you to use your own pot.

It’s also the only kit with full testing gear. Northern Brewer lists a triple-scale hydrometer, a test jar and a lab thermometer. The maker says they let you track fermentation and test your final ABV.

Fermentation happens in a siphonless 6.5 gallon fermenter with a gasketed lid and a bubbler airlock. A separate bottling bucket with a spigot and a spring-tip bottle filler handles bottling, so there’s no siphon to start.

The kit includes Northern Brewer’s no-rinse cleanser, a bottle brush, tubing, and a bottle capper with caps. The listing counts 60 caps. Bottles aren’t in the box.

The listing says one batch yields 5 gallons and fills 50 twelve-ounce bottles. Northern Brewer’s own page calls it 2 cases.

Chinook IPA is described as an American IPA that’s lighter in body than Northern Brewer’s other IPAs, with a resinous Chinook hop aroma. The same kit is sold with Block Party Amber Ale or Hank’s Hefeweizen if you’d like something less hoppy.

Help comes with it. Northern Brewer lists printed step-by-step instructions, a free Homebrewing 101 course, and brewmasters you can reach by text, chat or email. The company says it has been in homebrew supply since 1993.

It ties for the top score at 9.5. Our call: the most complete first kit, if you have room for 5 gallons.

Best for 5 gallons in your own pot

Craft A Brew Everyday 5 gallon

Hefeweizen recipe, 5 gallon
$129.00
Check it on Amazon
low stock · price as of Nov 16, 2026, 5:34 AM EST
9.5Spec scoreHow it’s scored
Cleaning10
Transfer10
Bottling8
Measuring10

Pros

  • Hydrometer, thermometer and a stick-on thermometer
  • Fermenting and bottling buckets with spigots
  • Capper and 50 caps
  • Recipe with steeping grains and fresh hops
  • Maker promises help or replacement parts

Cons

  • No brew kettle
  • Bottles not included
  • Needs room for two 6.5 gallon buckets
  • Recipe choice limited to three styles
5 gal batch6.5 gal bucketsHydrometer50 capsCapperSku 5BK-BUCKET-HEF

Buy it if

You already own a big stock pot and want a full 5-gallon setup with testing gear.

Skip it if

You don’t own a pot big enough to boil in. The Northern Brewer kit includes a 5 gallon kettle.

The Everyday 5 Gallon is Craft A Brew’s bucket kit for full-size batches. This listing comes with the Hefeweizen recipe. It was new, sold by Craft a Brew and in stock at our 2:36 AM check on Oct 22.

Its contents nearly match the Northern Brewer kit. Craft A Brew lists a 6.5 gallon fermentation bucket with a spigot and lid, a 6.5 gallon bottling bucket with a spigot, a 3-piece airlock and 5/16 in. transfer tubing.

For bottling there’s a spring-tip bottling wand, a bottle capper and 50 bottle caps. Bottles aren’t included.

Testing gear is generous: a hydrometer, a thermometer and a Fermometer, which is an adhesive thermometer that sticks to the bucket so you can read the temperature while it ferments.

The recipe kit has dry malt extract, specialty grains, fresh hops, yeast, a grain steeping bag and sanitizer, per the listing. You can choose American Pale Ale, Hefeweizen or Oktoberfest. The maker says a batch makes about 50 bottles.

What’s missing is the pot. Craft A Brew’s list has no kettle, so you’ll need your own to steep the grains and boil. If you already have one, this kit and the Northern Brewer give you the same core setup.

Craft A Brew calls this kit a good fit for beginners and for brewers moving up from 1-gallon batches. Its equipment works with the company’s other 5-gallon recipe kits for later batches.

The company backs its kits with what it calls the “We Got You” guarantee: if a first batch goes wrong, it says it will help you troubleshoot or replace what you need.

It ties for the top score at 9.5. Our call: the 5-gallon kit to get if you already own a big pot.

Best for bottles in the box

BrewDemon Signature 2 gallon

Signature Pro, 2 gallon
$135.00
Check it on Amazon
in stock · price as of Nov 16, 2026, 5:34 AM EST
9.5Spec scoreHow it’s scored
Cleaning10
Transfer10
Bottling10
Measuring8

Pros

  • Bottles, caps and labels included
  • Conical fermenter traps sediment
  • Tap and bottle filler, no siphon
  • Airlock upgrade included
  • Short stovetop prep, per the listing

Cons

  • No hydrometer
  • Temperature read from a stick-on gauge
  • No brew kettle
  • 2 gallons per batch
2 gal batchConical fermenter8 × 1 L bottlesTap + fillerTemp gaugeModel 80200

Buy it if

You want everything to bottle your first batch in one box, in a size that fits on a counter.

Skip it if

You want to measure gravity and alcohol. The Northern Brewer kit includes a hydrometer.

The Signature kit is BrewDemon’s 2-gallon conical fermenter set. It was new, sold by BrewDemon and in stock at our 2:36 AM check on Oct 22.

It’s labeled for bottles in the box because it has everything to fill and seal them. BrewDemon lists bottles, caps and labels, a bottle filler and hose, and an adjustable flow tap. The listing counts eight 1-liter amber bottles.

The fermenter is the other draw. BrewDemon calls it the world’s first patented small-batch conical fermenter. The listing says the cone traps sediment at the bottom, so you can bottle straight from the tap without a siphon.

It vents through a plug rather than an airlock. BrewDemon still includes an airlock upgrade with a lid gasket and drilled stopper, so you can switch if you prefer to watch it bubble.

Cleaning is covered by One Step no-rinse cleanser, and a heat-tolerant plastic spoon handles mixing. The recipe comes with dry brewing yeast, and BrewDemon says the beer is 100% malt with a golden color.

Measuring is its weak spot. There’s a stick-on temperature gauge but no hydrometer, so it scores 8 on that check. You can follow the instructions without one, but you won’t know your exact ABV.

BrewDemon says the vent plug lets CO2 escape while keeping contaminants out, and the listing says the fermenter takes an airlock or a blow-off tube. The listing also adds a priming sugar scoop for carbonation.

The listing says the kit makes 16 pints and the stovetop prep takes about 15 minutes. There’s no kettle in the box; you’ll use a kitchen pot.

It ties for the top score at 9.5. Our call: the kit with the least extra shopping before your first beer is in bottles.

Best for a 30-minute brew day

Mr. Beer 4 gallon kit

2 refills, 2 gallons each
$59.99
Check it on Amazon
low stock · price as of Nov 16, 2026, 5:34 AM EST
9.0Spec scoreHow it’s scored
Cleaning10
Transfer10
Bottling10
Measuring6

Pros

  • About 30 minutes of brewing, per the maker
  • 11 reusable bottles and caps included
  • Two refills for two batches
  • Carbonation drops, no sugar to measure
  • Sold by Amazon.com

Cons

  • No hydrometer or thermometer
  • Hopped extract gives fewer recipe choices
  • 2 gallons per batch
  • Plastic bottles only
2 × 2 gal2 gal fermenter11 × 740 mL bottlesSpigotCarb dropsSku 26265

Buy it if

You want the simplest start, with bottles included and no big pot to buy.

Skip it if

You want to learn grain steeping and hop additions. The Craft A Brew 1 gallon teaches the full process.

This is Mr. Beer’s Complete Bonus kit, which comes with two refills. It was new, sold by Amazon.com and in stock at our 2:36 AM check on Oct 22.

It’s labeled for a 30-minute brew day because it uses hopped malt extract. The listing says you can brew a batch in less than 30 minutes and have beer ready to drink in 3 to 4 weeks. Mr. Beer’s own page gives a longer wait: about 3 weeks to ferment and 2 weeks to carbonate, about 4 to 5 weeks in all.

It also needs the least extra equipment. The listing says there’s no need for large pots or strainers, just water and common kitchen items.

Mr. Beer’s own page lists the contents: a 2-gallon fermenter with lid and spigot, 11 reusable 740 mL PET bottles with caps, carbonation drops, a packet of no-rinse cleanser and step-by-step instructions.

The two refills are Oktoberfest Lager and Canadian Blonde. Mr. Beer says each makes 8 liters, about 2 gallons, so the kit brews about 4 gallons across two batches. By our arithmetic, the 11 bottles hold 8.14 liters, one full batch.

Carbonation drops replace measured priming sugar. You drop them into each bottle before filling.

There’s no testing gear at all, so it scores 6 on the measuring check and 9.0 overall. Mr. Beer’s 2-gallon listing says hopped extract cuts brewing time, reduces the risk of contamination and gives more consistent beer.

The trade-off is control. With a pre-hopped extract, you don’t choose your own hops or steep grains on these first two batches. Mr. Beer says the fermenter, bottles and caps are reusable, so later batches only need a refill or recipe kit.

Our call: the easiest first batch on this list, with bottles included.

Best for watching it ferment in glass

Craft A Brew 1 gallon Hefeweizen

Hefeweizen, 1 gallon
$52.95
Check it on Amazon
in stock · price as of Nov 16, 2026, 5:34 AM EST
8.0Spec scoreHow it’s scored
Cleaning10
Transfer8
Bottling6
Measuring8

Pros

  • 1-gallon glass carboy you can see through
  • Thermometer, funnel and airlock
  • Full recipe: grains, hops and yeast
  • Sanitizer and a brewing guide
  • Assembled by hand in Orlando, per the listing

Cons

  • No bottles, caps or capper
  • Racking cane means siphoning
  • No hydrometer
  • Makes 10 to 12 bottles
1 gal batchGlass carboyRacking caneThermometer10–12 bottlesSku BK-HEF

Buy it if

You want to learn the full process in a small batch and watch fermentation through glass.

Skip it if

You want bottles in the box. The BrewDemon and Mr. Beer kits include them.

This is Craft A Brew’s 1-gallon Hefeweizen beer making kit. It was new, sold by Craft a Brew and in stock at our 2:36 AM check on Oct 22.

It’s labeled for watching it ferment because it uses a 1-gallon glass carboy, a glass jug you can see straight through. A rubber stopper and airlock seal it.

It teaches the full process in miniature. Craft A Brew’s steps are to steep the wheat grains, boil the wort, add hops, ferment with Weizen ale yeast, then bottle and let the beer carbonate naturally.

The kit includes a funnel, a thermometer, a racking cane, transfer tubing with a clamp, sanitizer and Craft A Brew’s Guide to Craft Brewing. The recipe has wheat malt, specialty grains, hops and Weizen ale yeast. Craft A Brew describes the result as a light, citrusy German-style wheat beer with subtle banana and clove notes and a natural haze.

Moving the beer means siphoning with the racking cane, so it scores 8 on the transfer check. Bottling is its weak spot: the maker’s list has no bottles, caps or capper, so it scores 6 there.

The thermometer earns 8 on measuring. There’s no hydrometer, so you’ll follow the recipe’s timing rather than test the beer’s gravity before bottling.

Craft A Brew says the batch makes 10 to 12 bottles and is ready to drink in about four weeks. That matches our arithmetic: a gallon fills about 10 twelve-ounce bottles.

You’ll also need a pot to steep and boil in. Craft A Brew says all the equipment is reusable for future batches.

It scores 8.0. Our call: a small, honest first batch, once you’ve bought bottles, caps and a capper.

Best for a small batch with no siphon

Northern Brewer Siphonless 1 gallon

Caribou Slobber Brown Ale, 1 gallon
$86.66
Check it on Amazon
in stock · price as of Nov 16, 2026, 5:34 AM EST
7.3Spec scoreHow it’s scored
Cleaning5
Transfer10
Bottling8
Measuring6

Pros

  • Siphonless fermenter, no racking
  • Bottle capper and caps
  • Recipe with fresh ingredients
  • Free Homebrewing 101 course
  • Personalizable bottle labels

Cons

  • Needs about 12 bottles and a 2 gallon kettle
  • No hydrometer or thermometer
  • Sanitizer on the listing, not the maker’s list
  • 1 gallon per batch
1 gal batchSiphonless bubblerCapperAbout 12 bottlesLabelsSku 7611C

Buy it if

You want a small first batch without learning to siphon, and you have a 2 gallon pot and a dozen pry-off bottles.

Skip it if

You want testing gear. The Craft A Brew 1 gallon at least includes a thermometer.

This is Northern Brewer’s Siphonless 1-gallon craft beer making kit with the Caribou Slobber Brown Ale recipe. It was new, sold by Northern Brewer and in stock at our 2:36 AM check on Oct 22.

It’s labeled for no siphon because of its fermenter, the Little Big Mouth Bubbler. Northern Brewer made it siphonless to cut the number of tools and some of the steps in brewing.

Northern Brewer’s page lists the bubbler, a step-by-step instruction packet, a bottle capper and caps, personalizable bottle labels, a free Homebrewing 101 course and the recipe kit.

The Amazon listing adds a bottle filler and Northern Brewer’s No Rinse Oxygen Wash, and calls the bubbler glass with a cap and airlock. When the maker’s list and the listing differ, we score the maker’s shorter list.

That’s why it scores 5 on cleaning and 7.3 overall, the lowest here and still above our 7.0 floor. If your box has the cleanser, you have what you need.

There’s no testing gear, so it scores 6 on measuring. Help comes as a free Homebrewing 101 course, and the listing promises easy instructions and customer service to answer your questions.

Northern Brewer is clear about what else you need: about 12 pry-off 12 oz bottles and a 2 gallon kettle. Its note asks for pry-off bottles, not twist-off ones, to go with the capper and pry-off caps in the box.

The recipe is what Northern Brewer calls fresh ingredients, not a pre-hopped malt extract in a can. Caribou Slobber is its best-selling brown ale: dark, smooth and full-bodied without much bitterness. The kit also comes in Irish Red Ale, Kama Citra and American Wheat.

Our call: a small, simple first batch for someone who already has a pot and some bottles.

The six kits compared

From each maker’s list of what’s included. Scroll sideways on a phone; tap a number heading to sort on a desktop.

KitSpec scoreGallons per batchKettleHydrometerBottlesTransferBuy
Northern Brewer Brew Share Enjoy9.55Included, 5 galYesBring your ownSpigot bucketsCheck it on Amazon
Craft A Brew Everyday 5 gallon9.55Use your ownYesBring your ownSpigot bucketsCheck it on Amazon
BrewDemon Signature 2 gallon9.52Use your ownNo8 × 1 LTapCheck it on Amazon
Mr. Beer 4 gallon9.02 (×2 refills)Kitchen pot will doNo11 × 740 mLSpigotCheck it on Amazon
Craft A Brew 1 gallon8.01Use your ownNoBring your ownRacking caneCheck it on Amazon
Northern Brewer Siphonless 1 gallon7.312 gal neededNoAbout 12 neededSiphonlessCheck it on Amazon

Every kit here includes a fermenter, an airlock or vent and a first recipe. Bottles, a big pot and testing gear are where they differ.

What’s in each box

Item by item, from each maker’s own list. A dash means the maker doesn’t list it.

ItemNB 5 galCAB 5 galBrewDemonMr. BeerCAB 1 galNB 1 gal
Brew kettle5 gal–––––
Fermenter6.5 gal bucket6.5 gal bucketConical2 gal keg1 gal glassBubbler
Airlock or ventYesYesVent + airlockLidYesListing only
Sanitizer or cleanserYesYesYesYesYesListing only
HydrometerYesYes––––
ThermometerYesYes + stick-onStick-on gauge–Yes–
Bottling bucket or tapYesYesTapSpigot––
Bottle capper and capsYesYes, 50 capsCapsCaps–Yes
Bottles––Yes11––
Recipe kitYesYesYes2 refillsYesYes

NB is Northern Brewer and CAB is Craft A Brew. Mr. Beer and BrewDemon include plastic PET bottles with their own caps, and neither lists a capper.

The Northern Brewer 1-gallon kit is the one case where the Amazon listing lists more than the maker. We score the maker’s list and flag the gap.

What you still need to buy

The shopping list each kit leaves you with, from the makers’ own notes and their lists of what’s included.

KitYou still needWhere the list comes from
Northern Brewer Brew Share EnjoyAbout 50 twelve-ounce pry-off bottlesListing: fills 50 twelve-ounce bottles; no bottles in the maker’s list
Craft A Brew Everyday 5 gallonA pot to boil in; about 50 bottlesNo kettle or bottles in the maker’s list
BrewDemon Signature 2 gallonA kitchen potNo kettle in the maker’s list
Mr. Beer 4 gallonWater and common kitchen itemsListing
Craft A Brew 1 gallonA pot; 10 to 12 bottles, caps and a capperNo pot, bottles, caps or capper in the maker’s list
Northern Brewer Siphonless 1 gallonAbout 12 pry-off bottles; a 2 gallon kettleNorthern Brewer’s own note

Bottles are the most common gap. Save pry-off bottles, the kind Northern Brewer’s note asks for, not twist-off ones.

For a pot, our stock pot guide compares pots by size. Northern Brewer’s own advice for 5-gallon batches is an 8 gallon kettle.

How much beer each kit makes

Batch size decides how many bottles you fill, and how long one brew day lasts you.

Northern Brewer 5 gal5 galCraft A Brew 5 gal5 galBrewDemon 2 gal2 galMr. Beer 4 gal2 gal per refillCraft A Brew 1 gal1 galNorthern Brewer 1 gal1 galNorthern Brewer 5 gal5 galCraft A Brew 5 gal5 galBrewDemon 2 gal2 galMr. Beer 4 gal2 gal per refillCraft A Brew 1 gal1 galNorthern Brewer 1 gal1 gal
Gallons per batch from each maker. Mr. Beer’s kit has two refills of about 2 gallons each.
Batch12 oz bottles, our mathWhat the makers say
5 gallons53Northern Brewer: 50 twelve-ounce bottles; Craft A Brew: about 50
About 2 gallons21Mr. Beer: 11 bottles of 740 mL per refill; BrewDemon: 16 pints
1 gallon10Craft A Brew: 10 to 12 bottles; Northern Brewer: about 12 bottles needed

Our math is gallons times 128 ounces, divided by 12. Real yields run a little lower, because some beer stays behind with the yeast at the bottom.

One 5-gallon brew day makes five times the beer of a 1-gallon batch. A 1-gallon batch takes less space and costs less to get wrong.

How long until you can drink it

Brewing is quick. Waiting is most of the job.

KitBrew-day prepReady to drinkSource
Mr. Beer 4 gallonAbout 30 minutes3 to 4 weeks (listing); about 4 to 5 weeks (maker)Listing and maker page
BrewDemon Signature 2 gallonAbout 15 minutes on the stoveNot statedListing
Craft A Brew 1 gallonSteep, boil and add hopsAbout 4 weeksMaker page
Northern Brewer and Craft A Brew 5 gallonSteep, boil and add hopsNot statedMaker pages

Mr. Beer breaks its time down on its 2-gallon listing: 10 to 14 days to ferment, then 7 to 14 more days in the bottle before it’s ready.

Craft A Brew’s four steps hold for every kit here: brew, ferment, bottle, then let the bottles carbonate before you drink.

Ingredient styleKitsWhat the makers say
Hopped malt extractMr. BeerCuts brewing time, reduces contamination risk, more consistent beer (Mr. Beer)
Malt extract recipe packBrewDemon100% malt beer, short stovetop prep (BrewDemon)
Malt extract, steeping grains, hops and yeastNorthern Brewer, Craft A BrewFresh ingredients, not a pre-hopped extract in a can (Northern Brewer)

Neither approach is wrong. Pre-hopped extract trades recipe control for a shorter, simpler day. Steeping grains and adding hops takes longer and teaches you how each part changes the beer.

RuleWhat TTB says
WhoAdults: 18 or older, or the legal age to buy beer where you are
How muchPer household per calendar year: 100 gallons with one adult, 200 gallons with two or more
TaxNo federal tax on beer made for personal or family use
SellingNot allowed: you can’t sell your beer or offer it for sale
SharingAllowed for personal or family use, including tastings and competitions
State and local lawFederal rules don’t override state or local law

Those rules come from the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB), under 26 U.S.C. 5053(e) and 27 CFR 25.205. Even the largest kit here sits far inside the limit: twenty 5-gallon batches would be 100 gallons.

Check your state’s rules before your first batch. TTB points readers to state alcohol control boards.

Four kinds of beer kit

This guide scores one kind: complete starter kits with equipment and a recipe.

KindWhat’s in itAn example we checkedIn this guide
Complete starter kitEquipment plus a first recipeAll six picksYes, scored
Equipment-only kitBuckets, airlock, hydrometer, capper; no recipeHome Brew Ohio Essential 5 gallon and Gold K7No, buy a recipe separately
Recipe or refill kitIngredients onlyCraft A Brew 5-gallon recipe kits and Mr. Beer refillsNo, for your second batch
All-in-one electric systemHeated mash and boil vessel, often with a pumpVEVOR and FOHERE 35 L systemsNo, a different kind
KitWhy it isn’t a pickWhat it does well
Northern Brewer Essential Brew Share EnjoyOnly 3 left at our check, and no kettle or testing gearSame buckets and capper as the full kit
Mr. Beer 2 gallon Golden Ale kitA 2-gallon keg and 25 oz bottles like the 4-gallon kit, with one refill instead of twoSold by Amazon.com
Northern Brewer 1G Gift Set, Kama CitraIts contents weren’t on the maker pages we readGift box version of the 1-gallon kit
Home Brew Ohio Essential 5 gallonEquipment only; the listing says no recipe is includedAuto-siphon, hydrometer, capper, thermometer
VEVOR 35 L electric systemA brewing machine, sold by a third-party sellerHeats and pumps on its own

Which beer kit fits you?

Answer these in order. The first yes is usually your pick.

QuestionIf yesIf no
Do you want the shortest brew day and bottles in the box?Mr. Beer 4 gallonRead on
Do you want bottles included but a full recipe?BrewDemon Signature 2 gallonRead on
Do you want 5 gallons and have no big pot?Northern Brewer Brew Share EnjoyRead on
Do you want 5 gallons and own a big pot?Craft A Brew Everyday 5 gallonRead on
Do you want to watch it ferment in glass?Craft A Brew 1 gallonNorthern Brewer Siphonless 1 gallon

Space matters as much as batch size. The 5-gallon kits use two 6.5 gallon buckets. The 1 and 2-gallon kits fit on a counter or a closet shelf. Pick the size you have room to leave alone for a few weeks.

Planning to keep bottles cold? Our beverage fridge guide and mini fridge guide compare fridges by size.

Questions people ask

What is the best beer brewing kit for beginners?

For most beginners, the Northern Brewer Brew Share Enjoy kit, because it includes the kettle, a hydrometer and a thermometer. For the simplest start with bottles included, the Mr. Beer 4 gallon kit.

How long does it take to brew beer from a kit?

The brew day itself is short: under 30 minutes for Mr. Beer, per its listing. The wait is longer. Mr. Beer’s listing says 3 to 4 weeks to drink and its own page says about 4 to 5. Craft A Brew says about four weeks for its 1-gallon kit.

Is it legal to brew beer at home?

Federally, yes. TTB says adults may make beer for personal or family use without tax, up to 100 gallons a year in a one-adult household or 200 with two or more. You can’t sell it, and state or local law still applies.

How much beer does a 1-gallon kit make?

About 10 to 12 bottles. Craft A Brew says 10 to 12 for its 1-gallon kit, and a gallon is 128 ounces, or about 10 twelve-ounce bottles.

Do beer brewing kits come with bottles?

Some do. The Mr. Beer kit includes 11 bottles and the BrewDemon kit includes bottles, caps and labels. The Northern Brewer and Craft A Brew kits don’t include bottles.

Do I need a big pot to brew beer?

It depends on the kit. The Northern Brewer Brew Share Enjoy kit includes a 5 gallon kettle, its 1-gallon kit asks for a 2 gallon kettle, and Mr. Beer says common kitchen items will do.

What is a hydrometer for?

It measures how much sugar is in the beer. Northern Brewer says its testing equipment lets you track fermentation and test your final ABV. Only the two 5-gallon kits here include one.

Should I start with a 1-gallon or 5-gallon kit?

A 1-gallon kit fits on a counter and costs less to get wrong. A 5-gallon kit makes about 50 bottles from one brew day. Pick by the space you have and how much beer you want.

Can I reuse a beer making kit?

Yes. The makers say the equipment is reusable; you buy a new recipe or refill kit for each batch. Craft A Brew and Mr. Beer both sell refills that fit their kits.

What’s the difference between hopped extract and a grain recipe?

Hopped malt extract already has the hops in it, so brewing is faster and simpler. A recipe with steeping grains and separate hops takes longer and gives you more control over the beer.

Which beer kit is easiest?

The Mr. Beer kit, by its maker’s description: hopped extract, under 30 minutes of brewing, bottles and carbonation drops included, and no large pot needed.

Do I need to sanitize everything?

Yes. Every kit here includes a sanitizer or no-rinse cleanser for that reason, apart from the Northern Brewer 1-gallon kit, whose maker list leaves it out while its Amazon listing includes it.

How we pick beer brewing kits

How we pick

We looked for complete beer starter kits, with equipment and a first recipe, whose maker publishes a list of what’s included. We kept six that score 7.0 or more on one formula.

At 2:36 AM on Oct 22, 2026, the Amazon listings showed each kit new and in stock, sold by its maker or Amazon.com.

Why trust us

Isaac Daniels owns and edits Plain Buy Guides. The contents, batch sizes and times on this page come from Northern Brewer, Craft A Brew, Mr. Beer and BrewDemon’s own product pages, with the Amazon listings where a maker is silent. The legal limits come from TTB. Each source is named below.

The spec score, check by check

Each check scores 0 to 10 from the maker’s list of what’s included and counts one quarter of the total. A kit needs 7.0 to be picked. When the maker’s list and the Amazon listing differ, we score the maker’s shorter list. It’s our score, not a customer rating.

Check (weight)How it’s scored
Cleaning (1/4)10 when a sanitizer or no-rinse cleanser is included; 5 when the maker doesn’t list one
Transfer (1/4)10 for a spigot, tap or siphonless fermenter; 8 for a racking cane and tubing; 5 for nothing
Bottling (1/4)10 when bottles and caps are included; 8 for a capper and caps without bottles; 6 for no caps or capper
Measuring (1/4)10 for a hydrometer and thermometer; 8 for a thermometer or stick-on gauge only; 6 for neither
TotalAverage of the four, to one decimal
KitCleaningTransferBottlingMeasuringScore
Northern Brewer Brew Share Enjoy10108109.5
Craft A Brew Everyday 5 gallon10108109.5
BrewDemon Signature 2 gallon10101089.5
Mr. Beer 4 gallon10101069.0
Craft A Brew 1 gallon108688.0
Northern Brewer Siphonless 1 gallon510867.3

Sources

  • Northern Brewer, product pages for the Brew Share Enjoy Homebrew Starter Kit, Essential Brew Share Enjoy Starter Kit, Craft Beer Making Kit 1 Gallon and Essential Beer Making Kit 1 Gallon, read Oct 22, 2026
  • Craft A Brew, product pages for The Everyday 5 Gallon Beer Brewing Kit and the Hefeweizen Beer Making Kit, read Oct 22, 2026
  • Mr. Beer, product page for the Complete Bonus Complete Beer Making Kit (contents, refills and FAQ), read Oct 22, 2026
  • BrewDemon, product pages for the 2 Gal. Signature Beer Brewing Kit and 1 Gal. Craft Beer Starter Kits, read Oct 22, 2026
  • Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB), Beer FAQs: beer for personal or family use under 26 U.S.C. 5053(e) and 27 CFR 25.205–25.206, read Oct 22, 2026
  • Amazon listings for the six picks and for the Mr. Beer 2 gallon Golden Ale, Northern Brewer Essential and 1G Gift Set, Home Brew Ohio and VEVOR kits, read Oct 22, 2026
  • Amazon offer and image reads, Oct 22, 2026, 2:36 AM EDT

Related guides