As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Our product guides include affiliate links to Amazon.
Bug repellents: choose the active ingredient and format
For personal insect repellent, compare the exact formula and label: OFF! Deep Woods Dry is a 25% DEET aerosol two-pack; Sawyer SP564 is a 20% picaridin lotion; Repel HG-94211 is a 30% oil-of-lemon-eucalyptus aerosol. The lotion is included as a non-spray format choice. None is interchangeable with wasp killer or bear spray.
Checked October 14, 2026 against the named brand Amazon listings and primary sources below. We compared published specs and fit limits; picks are built from the makers' published specs and manuals.
Select a personal repellent, not nest killer, bear deterrent or an unlabeled clothing treatment.
Active and format
Read the exact concentration and aerosol/lotion selection.
People and materials
Check age limits, skin/clothing directions and material warnings.
Current label
Use its reapplication, storage and disposal instructions rather than a universal schedule.
EPA directs users to follow the product label and notes that conditions such as perspiration, water exposure and temperature can change effectiveness. These picks are built from the makers' published specs and manuals.
The selected Deep Woods Dry offer contains two four-ounce cans. OFF! identifies its Dry VIII aerosol as 25% DEET, EPA registration 4822-572. Match the Dry formula and selected pack rather than assuming every Deep Woods bottle has the same concentration or dispenser.
The maker’s directions warn against contact with certain materials, including plastics, leather, spandex and painted or varnished surfaces. Read the full compatibility list before use around gear. “Dry” describes the marketed formulation.
Selected pack
2 × 4 oz aerosol cans
Active ingredient
25% DEET
Maker registration
4822-572
Watch for: Check current skin/clothing directions and material restrictions; not a universal gear treatment.
Picaridin lotion: Sawyer SP564 Picaridin Lotion, 4 oz
Sawyer identifies the selected four-ounce SP564 as lotion with 20% picaridin. Choose it when you want a lotion rather than either aerosol. Its exact maker page confirms one lotion bottle; a pump spray, continuous spray or clothing-treatment product is a different selection.
Some retail bullets call this a spray and give spray-duration language. Sawyer’s current maker page distinguishes lotion from spray and gives different duration claims. Follow the delivered lotion label’s application and reapplication limits.
Selected model
SP564
Selected format / pack
Lotion; one 4 oz bottle
Active ingredient
20% picaridin
Watch for: This is lotion, despite generic spray wording in some bullets. Use the lotion label, not directions from a different Sawyer product.
OLE aerosol: Repel Lemon Eucalyptus HG-94211, 4 oz
Repel’s HG-94211 maker page identifies a four-ounce aerosol with 30% oil of lemon eucalyptus and EPA registration 305-62. This formulated repellent is not a bottle of pure eucalyptus essential oil or a home-mixed substitute. The selected can is an aerosol, not the similarly named pump spray.
The current maker directions say not to use this product on children under three. EPA notes that age restrictions can differ among oil-of-lemon-eucalyptus product labels; that does not remove this selected product’s restriction. Repel also states that its DEET-free description is not a safety claim.
Selected model / format
HG-94211; 4 oz aerosol
Active ingredient
30% oil of lemon eucalyptus
Current maker age restriction
Not for children under 3
Watch for: Follow the selected can’s age and application restrictions. Plant-based and DEET-free do not establish a safety advantage.
Published details from the named brands; confirm the exact variant before ordering.
Pick
Choose it for
Check first
OFF! Deep Woods Dry, 4 oz, 2 Cans
DEET aerosol two-pack
Check current skin/clothing directions and material restrictions; not a universal gear treatment.
Sawyer SP564 Picaridin Lotion, 4 oz
Picaridin lotion
This is lotion, despite generic spray wording in some bullets. Use the lotion label, not directions from a different Sawyer product.
Repel Lemon Eucalyptus HG-94211, 4 oz
OLE aerosol
Follow the selected can’s age and application restrictions. Plant-based and DEET-free do not establish a safety advantage.
A lotion is a different selection from a spray
The selected Sawyer is a lotion bottle even though some retail bullets use generic spray wording. OFF! and Repel are aerosols. Choose the delivery format you want and read the exact label; neither format establishes a shared application amount or a universal duration.
Check each product’s limits separately
Repel’s selected current label has an under-three restriction. OFF! lists specific material warnings. Sawyer’s lotion has its own directions rather than the spray’s. Do not turn an ingredient name, DEET-free claim or advertised time into a guarantee of protection from bites or disease.
Questions
Is the selected Sawyer SP564 a spray?
No. The exact selection is a four-ounce lotion bottle with 20% picaridin.
Does DEET-free mean safer?
No such comparison is established here. Repel explicitly says its DEET-free statement is not a safety claim; follow the exact product label.
OFF! Deep Woods Dry VIII (off.com) — 25% DEET, registration and material restrictions; no universal fabric compatibility.
Sawyer four-ounce picaridin lotion (sawyer.com) — Exact lotion format,20%active and distinction from spray; no fixed duration guarantee.
Repel HG-94211 (repel.com) — Exact30%OLE aerosol and under-three restriction; direct fetch saved after web-reader errors.
EPA — Using Insect Repellents Safely (epa.gov) — Current-label directions and differing OLE age restrictions; effects of conditions.
Listing details and availability can change. Our recommendations are built from the makers' published specs and manuals. All checked New offers were sold by Amazon.com. Recheck the selected variant, seller and stock status before ordering.