For most home bars, get the Breville Smoking Gun Pro: a dial turns the smoke down so the chips last, and its burn chamber and barrel go in the dishwasher. For a simpler two-speed gun, get the Breville Smoking Gun. For a lid and glass globes in the box, get the Homia kit.
Best for most home bars$159.95 at AmazonPrice as of Nov 16, 2026, 5:34 AM EST
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
How the three smoke guns score
One formula for all three: smoke control, cleaning, what’s in the box, warranty, and how much the maker publishes.
Plain Buy Guides spec score out of 10, from five checks on each maker’s own page, manual or listing. It’s our arithmetic, not a customer rating.
The three are close, and each one wins a different check. The Breville Pro is the only one with a speed dial, so it tops smoke control. The Homia is the only one with a lid in the box, so it tops the box check. All three burn chambers can go in the dishwasher, and all three carry a 1‑year warranty.
The Brevilles publish the most. Breville gives the power, the size, the materials, the box contents and a full manual for both guns. Homia gives everything but the size, which costs it a point on the spec sheet check.
The three smoke guns in detail
Best for most home bars
Breville Smoking Gun Pro
Product photo: Amazon
Smoking Gun Pro smoke infuser, black (CSM700PSS0NUC1)
You smoke drinks or plates often, or a round at a time, and want to turn the smoke down so the chips last.
Skip it if
You want a lid or glass in the box. The Homia kit includes a dome lid and two glass globes.
Breville’s Smoking Gun Pro, model CSM700, is a battery smoke gun with a speed dial, a removable burn chamber and a silicone hose. Breville sells it in its commercial line; Breville’s listings say PolyScience is now Breville Commercial. It was new, sold by Amazon.com and in stock at our 7:44 AM check on Oct 22.
The dial is the reason to pick it. Breville’s manual says the first click is maximum speed, for lighting the chips, and turning further slows the fan down to MIN so the chips smolder and make smoke. Breville says the slower burn makes the wood last longer when you smoke several portions.
Breville also calls the burn chamber extra large and says it and the variable speed allow longer smokes. That suits a round of smoked Old Fashioneds better than a single glass. Breville says its integrated base keeps it from tipping in use.
Cleaning scores full marks. The manual says the burn chamber, spring, barrel and O-ring can all go in the dishwasher. The fan slides off once you loosen its set screw with the hex key in the box; it’s hand wash only. Breville’s listing says reaching the fan and O-ring stops one smoke’s flavor carrying into the next.
In the box: four mesh filters, the hex key and a set screw, four AA batteries, an instruction book and two wood chip samples, hickory and applewood. There’s no lid. Breville’s own CSM018 glass cloche, 7 in. across and made for this gun, is sold separately.
Light it with a match or a lighter. The manual says not to use a kitchen torch or a butane torch-style lighter, since the extra heat can damage the unit, and to hold the flame only long enough to start the chips. The chips should just cover the mesh filter in a thin layer.
One detail doesn’t line up. Breville’s page describes a die-cast stainless steel barrel and burn chamber in one place and an anodized aluminum barrel and chamber in its spec list. Either way the parts are metal and dishwasher safe, and we list the conflict below.
It runs on four AA alkaline batteries; the manual rules out rechargeables. It measures 6.7 by 3.2 by 5.7 in. Its mesh filter is 1 in. across, larger than the Breville Smoking Gun’s ¾ in. filter, so order the right spares. The warranty is 1 year, limited.
It scores 9.2, losing points only on the box and the 1‑year warranty. Our call: the smoke gun to buy for most home bars, and the one built for long sessions.
Best for simple two-speed smoking
Breville the Smoking Gun
Product photo: Amazon
the Smoking Gun handheld smoker, silver (BSM600SIL)
4 × AA, 6 VGentle and Intense4.5 × 2.5 × 6.5 in.¾ in. mesh filterDie-cast stainless chamberModel BSM600
Buy it if
You want a simple smoke gun for drinks and plates at home, from a maker that documents it fully.
Skip it if
You smoke for a crowd and want to slow the burn. The Breville Pro’s dial turns the fan down further.
Breville’s the Smoking Gun, model BSM600 in silver, is the home version of the Pro: a battery fan, a removable burn chamber and a silicone hose, with two speeds. Serious Eats picks it too, alongside the Pro. It was new, sold by Amazon.com and in stock at our 7:44 AM check on Oct 22.
The two speeds are a switch, not a dial. Breville’s listing calls them Gentle and Intense. The manual says to start on high, marked with two lines, so the chips catch, then press the switch to low, one line, once smoke comes out of the hose.
The manual says this gun is for household use only. The Pro is rated for commercial and household use. For a home bar that smokes a drink or a plate at a time, that difference won’t matter.
Cleaning scores full marks. The manual says the burn chamber can go in the dishwasher or be washed by hand in warm, soapy water. You wipe the barrel, brush the mesh filter, and wash the hose in soapy water. The body gets a damp cloth and never goes in water.
In the box: two mesh filters plus replacement filters, four AA batteries, an instruction book with recipe cards, and hickory and applewood chip samples. There’s no lid. Breville’s BSM600AWC wood chip kit adds applewood, cherrywood, hickory and mesquite.
Light it with a match or a lighter. Like the Pro’s, this manual warns against kitchen and butane torches. It says to keep the gun at least 8 in. from walls and curtains, use it upright so hot chips can’t fall out, and never run it without the mesh filter.
Breville gives the size as 4.5 by 2.5 by 6.5 in., so it’s 2.2 in. narrower than the Pro and 0.8 in. taller. The burn chamber is die-cast stainless steel. The mesh filter is ¾ in. across, a No. 20 sieve in 304 stainless, which matters when you order spares.
It runs on four AA alkaline batteries, 6 V in all, and the manual rules out rechargeables. It can’t bubble smoke through a liquid; the manual says the fan isn’t strong enough. The warranty is 1 year, limited.
It scores 9.0, a point behind the Pro on smoke control. Our call: the simplest smoke gun to live with, for drinks and plates at home.
4 × AA includedOne speedMetal chamber and fan13 piecesFan up to 2.3 m/sHousehold use
Buy it if
You want everything for smoked drinks and plates in one box, including a lid to smoke under.
Skip it if
You want to slow the smoke down. The Breville Pro’s dial does that; the Homia has one speed.
Homia’s Birner Pro Premium Kit is a smoke gun packed with the extras the Brevilles leave out: 13 pieces, from a dome lid to two glass cocktail globes. Homia has its own site, manual and support line, and its manual gives a Fort Lauderdale, Florida address. The kit was new, sold by Homia and in stock at our 7:44 AM check on Oct 22.
Here’s the box, in Homia’s words: the smoke gun, a stand, a hose, a disk lid, a dome lid, two glass cocktail balls, four flavors of wood chips, a bubble nozzle, four AA batteries, three spare mesh filters, tweezers with a cleaning brush, and a screwdriver. Bubble mixture isn’t included.
That makes it the only pick with chips, batteries and a lid, so it scores 10 on our box check. The dome lid goes over a plate. Homia’s guide says to fill it with smoke for a few seconds, power off, and let the food sit 10 to 40 seconds before you lift it.
The glass globes are for drinks. Homia’s guide says to pour the drink into the globe, fill it with smoke for a few seconds, power off, plug it and turn it over. The bubble nozzle makes a smoke-filled bubble on a drink; Homia says to use a V-shaped glass, leave ½ in. at the top and skip the ice.
There’s one speed. Homia’s manual shows a single on button and says you change bubble size by pressing it or squeezing the hose. Its listing gives a fan speed of up to 2.3 m/s, the only fan figure any maker here publishes.
Mind the time limit. Homia’s manual says not to make smoke for longer than 30 seconds at a time, since longer runs may damage the unit. It also says to add no more than 2 pinches of chips and, like Breville, never to light them with a kitchen or butane torch.
Cleaning scores full marks, with one extra step. For a deep clean, you unscrew the bolts that hold the burn chamber with the included screwdriver; Homia says the chamber can then go in the dishwasher. After each use, you brush the mesh and wipe the chamber.
Homia publishes the box contents, the power, the materials (a metal chamber and fan) and a manual, but no size, so it scores 9 on the spec sheet check. Its support page lists a 1‑year warranty and 45-day returns. The manual says household use only.
It scores 8.8. Our call: the kit to buy if you want to smoke under a lid or in a glass globe on day one.
The three smoke guns compared
From each maker’s own page, manual or listing. Scroll sideways on a phone.
From Breville’s and Homia’s manuals, read Oct 22, 2026.
If you’re smoking
How, per the makers
Time
Manuals that describe it
A cocktail in the shaker
Make the drink in the shaker, fill it with smoke, take the hose out, put the lid on and shake.
No time given: the smoke goes in once, then you shake.
Breville Pro, Breville, Homia
A plate under an upturned glass
Plate the food, hold a drinking glass upside down and fill it with smoke, set it over the food, then lift it at the table.
The smoke soaks in while you serve.
Breville Pro, Breville, Homia
A plate under a cloche or lid
Cover the dish, put the hose under the lid and fill it with smoke, then let it stand.
A few minutes, per Breville; 10 to 40 seconds under Homia’s dome lid.
Breville Pro, Breville, Homia
Food in a covered bowl or bag
Cover the bowl with plastic wrap or use a sealable bag, put the hose in and fill it with smoke.
1 to 3 minutes (Breville Smoking Gun, Homia) or 1 minute (Breville Pro), repeated 2 or 3 times for more flavor.
Breville Pro, Breville, Homia
Whipped food in a stand mixer
Whip the food, spread it on the bowl walls, cover the bowl with plastic wrap and fill it with smoke.
1 minute, repeated 2 or 3 times for more flavor.
Breville Pro, Breville, Homia
A sauce or soup in a blender
Fill the blender, put the hose through the hole in the lid, blow smoke in, cap it and blend.
Repeat 2 or 3 times for more flavor.
Breville Pro
A cocktail in a glass globe
Pour the drink into the globe, fill it with smoke, power off, put the plug in and turn the globe over.
A few seconds of smoke.
Homia
A smoke bubble on a drink
Use a V-shaped glass with ½ in. left at the top and no ice, dip the bubble nozzle in bubble mixture and blow a bubble with smoke.
More smoke makes the bubble last longer, per Homia. Mixture is sold separately.
Homia
The table works without the planner. All three manuals say about the same thing: one to three minutes under smoke is generally all food needs, and you don’t need to keep smoking it. Put the hose just above the food, not in it.
None of the three can push smoke through a drink. The Breville Smoking Gun and Homia manuals both say the fan isn’t strong enough, and the Pro’s says it isn’t the intended use. Smoke the shaker, the glass or the air under a lid instead.
Smoke gun, smoke box or smoke top?
Three kinds of product share the name cocktail smoker. This guide scores the first.
Kind
How it works
How it’s lit
Examples
Handheld smoke gun
A battery fan draws smoke from a small burn chamber through a hose
Match or lighter, per Breville and Homia
Our three picks
Smoke box or cloche
A closed box or glass dome you fill with smoke from a gun
Wood chips sit on a lid over the glass and are lit directly
A torch; most kits in our search include one
Aged & Charred, Viski Alchemi, G&J’s Finest kits
A smoke gun is the most flexible kind. It fills a shaker, a glass, a bowl or a cloche, and it smokes food as well as drinks. That’s why every pick here is one, and why one formula is fair to all three.
Smoke tops work differently: you light the chips with a torch and the smoke rises into an upturned glass. They’re a different product with different checks, like the torch they come with, so we don’t score them against smoke guns.
How to light a smoke gun safely
All three manuals agree: light it with a match or a lighter, never a torch.
Breville and Homia both say to light the chips with a match or lighter and never with a kitchen or butane torch, since the extra heat can damage the gun. If you own a butane torch for other jobs, check it against CPSC’s recalls: Scripto Premium Torches (2025) and Sondiko butane torches (2025) were recalled for breaking the federal safety standard for multipurpose lighters.
What the manual says
Breville Pro
Breville Smoking Gun
Homia Birner
Light it with
Match or lighter
Match or lighter
Match or lighter
What may burn
Small wood chips, sawdust, dried herbs, spices, tea leaves
Small wood chips, sawdust, dried herbs, spices, tea leaves
Small wood chips, sawdust, dried herbs, spices, tea leaves
How much
A thin layer just covering the mesh
A thin layer just covering the mesh
No more than 2 pinches
How long
No limit given; cool between burns
No limit given; cool between burns
30 seconds of smoke at most
Where
8 in. from walls and curtains, upright
8 in. from walls and curtains, upright
8 in. from walls and curtains, upright
Rated for
Commercial and household use
Household use only
Household use only
Mesh filter
1 in. (25.4 mm), No. 20, 304 steel
¾ in. (19.0 mm), No. 20, 304 steel
3 spares included; size not stated
The manuals also agree on the air. Use the gun in a well-ventilated room, they say, because burning wood, herbs or tea gives off combustion by-products known to cause cancer, birth defects or reproductive harm. Breville’s product pages carry a California Proposition 65 warning for wood dust and carbon monoxide.
Keep it away from smoke alarms. Both Breville manuals and Homia’s say to avoid places where the smoke could set off an alarm or a sprinkler system. Never point the hose at a person, and empty the ash into something that can’t burn.
The mesh filter matters more than it looks. Every manual says never to run the gun without it, because glowing embers could get into the barrel or blow out of the hose. The Pro’s filter is 6.4 mm wider than the Breville Smoking Gun’s, so the two don’t share spares.
We found no recalls of any smoke gun in CPSC’s database: none for Breville’s smokers, PolyScience, Homia, Fortessa or Gramercy, and none for smoking guns or smoke infusers by name. Breville’s only recall in the database is a 2015 pressure cooker.
How to clean a smoke gun
From each maker’s care section. Let the gun cool and take the batteries out first.
Part
Breville Pro
Breville Smoking Gun
Homia Birner
Burn chamber
Dishwasher or hand wash
Dishwasher or hand wash
Dishwasher or hand wash; unscrew to remove
Barrel
Dishwasher or hand wash
Wipe clean
Not covered
Fan
Hand wash only; remove with the hex key
Not covered
Wipe the blades
Mesh filter
Warm soapy water and a small brush
Warm soapy water and a small brush
Warm soapy water and a small brush
Hose
Warm soapy water
Warm soapy water
Warm soapy water
Main body
Damp cloth; never in water
Damp cloth; never in water
Damp cloth; never in water
Tap out the ash first. Breville says to turn the burn chamber over and tap it on a solid surface once it’s cool, then wash it. Homia says to brush the mesh and wipe the chamber after each use, and to do a full clean with the screwdriver now and then.
All three manuals warn that resin from the smoke can stain your hands. Breville and Homia both say a clogged mesh filter should be replaced, and that the hose can be stored in a loop to keep the smell in. Take the batteries out if the gun will sit for a long time.
What else you need with each smoke gun
From each maker’s list of what’s in the box. The Brevilles need a lid for plates; the Homia needs nothing.
Smoke gun
In the box
Lid or cloche
Wood chips
Batteries
Breville Smoking Gun Pro
Gun, 4 mesh filters, hex key, set screw, manual
Sold separately
2 samples
4 × AA
Breville Smoking Gun
Gun, mesh filters and replacements, manual, recipe cards
For the Pro, Breville makes the CSM018 glass cloche: borosilicate glass, 7 in. across, with a one-way silicone valve. Its listing says a little smoke escaping at the rim while you fill it is normal. Any glass bowl turned upside down works for a single plate or drink.
For chips, Breville sells the BSM600AWC wood chip kit, four packs: applewood, cherrywood, hickory and mesquite. Breville’s manuals say to use chips made for smoking, since they’re dried to the right level and give off less resin.
Breville and Homia describe the same two woods in their manuals.
Wood
What the makers say
In the box
Hickory
Pungent, smoky, bacon-like; good with pork, beef and most vegetables
Breville Pro, Breville Smoking Gun
Applewood
Slightly sweet but denser and fruity; good with poultry, game birds and pork
Breville Pro, Breville Smoking Gun
Cherrywood and mesquite
In Breville’s BSM600AWC kit; not described in the manuals
Sold separately
Homia’s four flavors
Four flavors in the kit; Homia’s pages don’t name them
Homia Birner Pro kit
The manuals describe woods by the food they suit, not the drink. For a whiskey drink, the choice is taste: the same descriptions apply to the smoke in a glass. Start with a small amount, since all three manuals say one to three minutes under smoke is generally enough.
Dried herbs, spices and tea leaves are fine too, per every manual. Nothing else should go in the chamber. Breville’s Pro manual adds any other food that’s safe to eat. Never burn anything treated, painted or not meant for food.
What each maker publishes
The facts behind the scores. A blank on a maker’s page is a blank here.
Maker and model
Power
Size
Materials
Box contents
Manual
Warranty
Breville Smoking Gun Pro (CSM700)
4 × AA
6.7 × 3.2 × 5.7 in.
Metal barrel and chamber
Listed
Online
1 year
Breville Smoking Gun (BSM600)
4 × AA
4.5 × 2.5 × 6.5 in.
Die-cast stainless chamber
Listed
Online
1 year
Homia Birner Pro kit
4 × AA
Not stated
Metal chamber and fan
Listed
Online
1 year
BORUiT SK305 (left out)
2 × AA, not included
Not stated
Aluminum, zinc alloy, plastic
Listed
Not found
1 year
Crafthouse smoking box (left out)
Not stated
9.5 × 10.8 in. box
Walnut, steel, glass
Listed
Not found
Not stated
Gramercy kit (left out)
Not stated
Not stated
Aluminum and plastic
Listed
Not found
Not stated
Breville is the only maker that fills every box, for both guns, which is most of why they lead. Its manuals run to cleaning diagrams, filter specs and troubleshooting, and both are linked from Breville’s product pages.
The left-out guns show the opposite. Their Amazon listings are the only documents we could find, with no manual and, for two of them, no warranty term. That costs them on our checks, and it means fewer facts for you to go on.
Checked and left out
These came up in our search. Each one missed our 7.0 floor, wasn’t in stock or came from a brand we couldn’t check.
Gray bars are smoke guns we scored and left out, on the same five checks.
Smoke gun
Why it isn’t a pick
What it does well
BORUiT SK305
Scores 7.6, but a little-known brand with no maker site or manual we could find
Two smoke levels and a 1‑year warranty, per its listing
Crafthouse by Fortessa smoking box
Scores 6.2: the listing names no gun specs, care or warranty
Walnut, steel and glass box designed with bartender Charles Joly
Gramercy cocktail smoker kit
Scores 5.6: no speed, warranty, size or manual published
Wood chips, a cleaning brush and spare parts in the box
PolyScience Smoking Gun Pro set
Same gun as the Breville Pro, from a third-party seller with 5 left
Bundles the Pro with a glass cloche and wood chips
Homia Universal and older Birner kits
Not in stock at our check: a future ship date
Homia’s other bundles of the same idea
No-name gun and box kits
No maker documents to check
Often bundled with glasses, whiskey stones and ice molds
The BORUiT is the close call. On our checks it scores 7.6, above the floor. We left it out because BORUiT has no maker site or manual we could find, and our rules ask for well-known, documented brands. If that changes, it’s the first gun we’d check again.
The PolyScience set is the Breville Pro under its old brand name, with a cloche and chips. Breville’s listings say PolyScience is now Breville Commercial. Buying the Pro and Breville’s CSM018 cloche from Amazon.com gets you the same gun with Breville’s own dome.
Where the maker’s documents differ
We go by the manual where there is one, and say so when a page or listing reads differently.
Topic
One source says
Another says
What we did
Breville Pro barrel
Die-cast stainless steel (product page features)
Anodized aluminum (product page spec list)
Counted as published; no score depends on which
Breville Pro speeds
A dial from MAX to MIN (manual)
Gentle and intense settings (listing)
Scored the dial the manual shows
Time in a covered bowl
1 to 3 minutes (Breville Smoking Gun manual)
1 minute (Breville Pro manual)
Shown both in the planner
Homia warranty
1‑year warranty (support page)
Extended 1‑year warranty (listing)
Scored 1 year
Homia speed
One on button (manual)
Fan up to 2.3 m/s (listing)
Scored one speed
Which smoke gun fits your bar?
Answer these in order. The first yes is usually your pick.
Question
If yes
If no
Do you want a lid and glass globes in the box?
Homia Birner Pro kit
Read on
Do you smoke a round of drinks at a time?
Breville Smoking Gun Pro
Read on
Do you want the slimmest, simplest gun?
Breville Smoking Gun
Read on
Will you smoke plates often?
Breville Pro and its CSM018 cloche
Breville Smoking Gun Pro
Price isn’t in this table on purpose. Check the live prices on Amazon against what matters to you. The bigger differences are how finely you can set the smoke, what comes in the box, and how long the gun may run at a time.
Think about where you’ll use it. Every manual says to keep the gun 8 in. from walls and curtains, away from smoke alarms, on a level surface away from the edge. A bar cart under a smoke detector isn’t the spot.
Questions people ask
What is the best cocktail smoker?
For most home bars, the Breville Smoking Gun Pro: a speed dial from MAX to MIN, a dishwasher-safe burn chamber and barrel, and a full manual. For a simpler two-speed gun, the Breville Smoking Gun. For a lid and glass globes in the box, the Homia Birner Pro kit.
How do you use a cocktail smoker?
Put a thin layer of wood chips over the mesh filter, turn the fan to high and light the chips with a match or lighter. When smoke comes out of the hose, turn the fan down, then fill the shaker, glass or lid with smoke. That’s the method in Breville’s manuals.
How long do you smoke a cocktail?
Briefly. Homia says a few seconds of smoke in its glass globe, and 10 to 40 seconds under its dome lid. For the shaker method, all three makers say fill it with smoke, cover and shake, with no set time. For food, they say one to three minutes is generally enough.
Can you use a torch to light a smoking gun?
No. Breville’s and Homia’s manuals all say to use a match or lighter and never a kitchen or butane torch, since the extra heat can damage the gun. Hold the flame only long enough to start the chips.
What’s the difference between the Breville Smoking Gun and the Pro?
The Pro has a speed dial, a barrel that goes in the dishwasher along with the burn chamber, a removable fan, a 1 in. mesh filter and a rating for commercial use. The Smoking Gun has two speeds, a ¾ in. filter and is for household use only. Both take four AA batteries.
What wood chips are best for a cocktail smoker?
Breville’s manuals describe hickory as pungent and bacon-like and applewood as slightly sweet and fruity, and both Brevilles include samples of each. Use chips made for smoking: Breville says they’re dried to the right level and give off less resin.
Is smoking cocktails safe?
Follow the manual. The makers say to use a smoke gun only in a well-ventilated area, because burning wood gives off combustion by-products known to cause cancer, birth defects or reproductive harm, and to keep it away from smoke alarms.
Can a smoking gun bubble smoke through a drink?
No. The Breville Smoking Gun and Homia manuals say the fan isn’t strong enough, and the Pro’s says it isn’t the intended use. Homia’s bubble nozzle makes a smoke-filled bubble on top of the drink instead, with bubble mixture sold separately.
What batteries does the Breville Smoking Gun take?
Four AA alkaline batteries, 6 V in all, for both the Smoking Gun and the Pro. Both manuals say not to use rechargeable batteries. Four AA batteries come in the box.
Will a smoke gun set off a smoke alarm?
It can. Both Breville manuals and Homia’s say to avoid using the gun where the smoke could set off a smoke alarm or a fire sprinkler system.
How do you clean a smoking gun?
Let it cool, take the batteries out and tap the ash from the burn chamber. All three makers say the burn chamber can go in the dishwasher. Brush the mesh filter and wash the hose in warm soapy water; wipe the body with a damp cloth and never put it in water.
Is a smoke gun better than a smoke top?
It’s more flexible. A smoke gun fills a shaker, glass, bowl or cloche and smokes food as well as drinks, lit with a match or lighter. A smoke top sits on one glass and is lit with a torch, which most smoke-top kits in our search include.
How we pick cocktail smokers
How we pick
We looked for handheld smoke guns from makers that publish a manual, checked each against the maker’s own pages, manual and listing, and kept the ones that score 7.0 or more on one formula. Guns that weren’t in stock were left out.
At 7:44 AM on Oct 22, 2026, the Amazon listings showed all three new and in stock, sold by Amazon.com and by Homia.
Why trust us
Isaac Daniels owns and edits Plain Buy Guides. The specs here come from Breville’s and Homia’s product pages, instruction manuals and support pages, with CPSC for recalls. Each source is named below.
The spec score, check by check
Each check scores 0 to 10 and counts one fifth of the total. Only the maker’s statements count, on its own site, in its manual or on its own Amazon listing, and anything not stated scores 5. Where they differ, we go by the manual. A gun needs 7.0 to be picked. It’s our score, not a customer rating.
Check (weight)
How it’s scored
Smoke control (1/5)
10 for a variable speed dial; 9 for two settings; 7 for one; 5 if not stated
Cleaning (1/5)
10 if the maker says the burn chamber is dishwasher safe; 8 for a removable chamber; 7 if cleaning tools are included; 5 if not stated
In the box (1/5)
Of wood chips, batteries and a lid or cloche: all 3 = 10; 2 = 8; 1 = 6; none = 5
Warranty (1/5)
10 for lifetime; 9 for 2 years or more; 8 for 1 year; 5 if not stated
Spec sheet (1/5)
Of power, size, materials, box contents and a manual, the maker publishes: all 5 = 10; 4 = 9; 3 = 8; 2 or fewer = 5
Total
Average of the five, to one decimal
Smoke gun
Smoke control
Cleaning
In the box
Warranty
Spec sheet
Score
Breville Smoking Gun Pro
10
10
8
8
10
9.2
Breville Smoking Gun
9
10
8
8
10
9.0
Homia Birner Pro kit
7
10
10
8
9
8.8
BORUiT SK305
9
7
6
8
8
7.6
Crafthouse smoking box
5
5
8
5
8
6.2
Gramercy kit
5
7
6
5
5
5.6
Sources
Breville, the Smoking Gun (BSM600) product page and instruction book, breville.com, read Oct 22, 2026
Breville, the Smoking Gun Pro (CSM700) product page and instruction book, breville.com, read Oct 22, 2026
Homia, Birner Smoking Gun Premium Kit product page, Birner support page and Birner user manual, homia.us, read Oct 22, 2026
Breville Commercial CSM018 glass cloche and BSM600AWC wood chip kit Amazon listings, read Oct 22, 2026
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, recall searches for smoking guns, smoke infusers, cocktail and food smokers, Breville, PolyScience, Homia, Fortessa and Gramercy, and recalls of Scripto Premium Torches (2025) and Sondiko butane torches (2025), saferproducts.gov, read Oct 22, 2026
Serious Eats, cocktail smoker picks, seriouseats.com, read Oct 22, 2026
Amazon listings for the three picks and the left-out smokers, read Oct 22, 2026
Amazon offer and image reads, Oct 22, 2026, 7:44 AM EDT