As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Our product guides include affiliate links to Amazon.
Dishwashers: choose the installation before the wash modes
Choose between a full-width built-in, a narrow built-in and a countertop machine before comparing cycle names. GE GDF510PSRSS occupies a nominal 24-inch bay, Midea MDF18A1AST is the narrow option, and COMFEE CDC17P2AWW has a refillable tank. A tank changes how you add water; drainage still needs a suitable route.
Checked October 14, 2026 against the named brand Amazon listings and primary sources below. We compared published specs and fit limits; picks are built from the makers' published specs and manuals.
Built-in cabinet bay or a countertop location with room for the open door.
Water and drainage
Check the supply or filling route, drain destination, hoses and faucet compatibility.
Electrical
Verify the exact manual’s connection requirements; do not infer from nominal width.
Load
Compare your actual plates, pans and utensils with the rack drawing and capacity limits.
Place-setting counts describe published capacities, not a guarantee that your largest cookware fits. Installation and disposal services are separate unless the seller confirms them.
The picks, and why
Full-width built-in: GE GDF510PSRSS Dishwasher
The listing identifies GE GDF510PSRSS, and GE’s model page publishes product dimensions of 23.75 inches wide, 24 deep and 33.375 high. This is the full-width built-in option for a kitchen with a matching opening and installation services.
GE’s page displays limited-clearance and no-longer-manufactured messaging alongside availability templates. The checked New Amazon offer was available through BrandsMartUSA. Confirm exact stock, delivery coverage, warranty eligibility and installation before ordering this older model.
Format
Nominal 24-inch built-in
GE product size
23.75 W × 24 D × 33.375 H inches
Controls
Front controls
Watch for: Discontinued/clearance wording on GE’s page; a New retail offer does not establish current manufacture or an included installation service. The checked New offer was sold by BrandsMartUSA, rather than Amazon.com.
Midea identifies MDF18A1AST as an 18-inch-class built-in dishwasher with eight place settings, six cycles and a stainless steel tub. Its user manual gives dimensions of 17.6 inches wide, 22.6 deep and 32.4 high, with 120 V, 60 Hz power.
Midea’s web specification table uses slightly different rounded dimensions and contradicts its own marketing about rack adjustment. Use the actual installation drawing for fit and verify the rack configuration; we do not promise an adjustable upper rack. This is not a freestanding under-sink appliance.
Format
Nominal 18-inch built-in
Capacity
8 place settings, per Midea
Manual size
17.6 W × 22.6 D × 32.4 H inches
Watch for: Web table rounds the dimensions differently. Confirm clearances, connections and rack features against the current manual.
Countertop tank format: COMFEE CDC17P2AWW Dishwasher
COMFEE’s exact product page identifies CDC17P2AWW with a two-place-setting capacity and 120 V power. The listing describes a 6 L tank, an optional faucet connection with included adapter, and an automatic door-opening function.
This format needs dedicated counter space and a suitable drain destination. The maker-linked manual’s table labels the body as 16 9/16 inches wide, 17 1/8 deep and 18 5/16 high. Leave additional room for top filling, hoses and the opening door; the maker web table uses different, unlabeled dimensions.
Format
Countertop; 6 L tank, per listing
Maker capacity
2 place settings
Manual table size
16 9/16 W × 17 1/8 D × 18 5/16 H inches
Watch for: Confirm the current unit drawing, filling clearance and drain setup. Auto-opening needs space and suitable surrounding surfaces.
Published details from the named brands; confirm the exact variant before ordering.
Pick
Choose it for
Check first
GE GDF510PSRSS Dishwasher
Full-width built-in
Discontinued/clearance wording on GE’s page; a New retail offer does not establish current manufacture or an included installation service. The checked New offer was sold by BrandsMartUSA, rather than Amazon.com.
Midea MDF18A1AST Dishwasher
Narrow built-in
Web table rounds the dimensions differently. Confirm clearances, connections and rack features against the current manual.
COMFEE CDC17P2AWW Dishwasher
Countertop tank format
Confirm the current unit drawing, filling clearance and drain setup. Auto-opening needs space and suitable surrounding surfaces.
Measure before replacing a built-in
Measure the finished opening, including height below the counter and the floor level beneath the old machine. Compare those measurements with the installation drawing and adjustment range. Product body dimensions do not automatically include every clearance or hose bend.
The narrow Midea is not a direct width match for a nominal 24-inch GE bay. Neither built-in becomes a countertop appliance simply because its body fits somewhere. Have the intended installation, water connection and drainage checked before purchasing.
A tank does not remove the drain requirement
The COMFEE can take manually added water instead of relying on a faucet connection for filling. You still need space for filling, a suitable drain arrangement and room for the door to open. Check that your countertop and nearby cabinets suit the maker’s installation directions.
Cycle names such as Hygiene, Sanitize or Dry Boost are not a basis here for a sterilization promise or guaranteed drying result. These picks are built from the makers' published specs and manuals. Use only the detergent type and loading directions specified in the exact manual.
Questions
Will the countertop model replace a full-size load?
COMFEE lists two place settings, while Midea lists eight. Check actual dish dimensions and rack layouts instead of treating all compact machines as equivalent.
Is installation included?
Only if the seller’s terms specifically say so. Confirm parts, connection work, delivery coverage and old-appliance removal separately.
GE — GDF510PSRSS (geappliances.com) — Exact identity, dimensions and older-model status messaging.
Midea — MDF18A1AST user manual (midea.com) — Manual product dimensions, power and capacity; web table differences noted.
Midea — MDF18A1AST (midea.com) — Exact model; conflicting rack and rounded dimensions not treated as settled.
COMFEE — CDC17P2AWW (shop.feelcomfee.com) — Two-place-setting capacity and unlabeled dimension-order table; current model manual linked there.
COMFEE — CDC17P2AWW manual (shop.feelcomfee.com) — Maker-linked PDF read: page2 drainage/power, page26 drain restrictions and page31 labeled dimension table; page31 also visually checked.
Listing details and availability can change. Our recommendations are built from the makers' published specs and manuals. Checked sellers other than Amazon.com: BrandsMartUSA. Recheck the selected variant, seller and stock status before ordering.