As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Our product guides include affiliate links to Amazon.
Exact models and buying options
Dimplex Winslow 48 - SWM4820
Choose the Winslow 48 for a slim fireplace that hangs on a wall or sits on a table. Dimplex lists it as 48 inches wide, 18-1/8 inches high and 5 inches deep, with a viewing area of 36-3/8 by 8-3/4 inches. The included table stand brings the height to 20-7/8 inches and the depth to 10-7/8 inches.
Dimplex rates it at 120 volts, 1,400 watts and 12 amps, and says the fan-forced heater gives on-demand heat for up to 1,000 square feet at 5,000 BTU. Dimplex also says you can enjoy the flames without the heat. The media bed comes with three included options (crystals, logs or pebbles), and Dimplex lists a remote and an included table stand. Dimplex lists eight ember bed colors, three backlight colors, hidden touch controls and a timer that can be set for up to 8 hours.
It plugs into a standard household outlet; the manual says never to use it with an extension cord or a relocatable power tap (outlet/power strip). For care, the manual recommends cleaning or vacuuming the fan, heater and vents at least at yearly intervals, and warns that brass polish or household cleaners will damage the metal trim.
Listing differences: The checked Amazon listing gives 45.2 lb, 4,777 BTU and a 90-day warranty. Dimplex prints 36.4 lb for the fireplace and 46.5 lb packaged, 5,000 BTU, and a 12-month limited warranty (1 yr. on the spec sheet). Confirm the warranty in writing if the listing figure matters to you.
Warranty: Glen Dimplex Americas warrants the product against defects in material and workmanship for 12 months from the first purchase. It covers the original purchaser only, is not transferable, and applies only to purchases in Canada (except Yukon, Nunavut and the Northwest Territories) and the 50 US states and DC except Hawaii and Alaska; products bought in those excluded areas are sold as is.
Light bulbs are excluded. It does not apply to products repaired by anyone but Glen Dimplex Americas or its authorized service representatives, or otherwise altered, or to defects from misuse, abuse, accident, neglect, incorrect installation, improper maintenance or handling, or an incorrect power source. Proof of purchase is required; call Technical Service at 1-888-346-7539 with the model and serial numbers.
Dimplex repairs or replaces at its discretion, or may refund instead. You pay removal, transport to and from the authorized dealer or service agent, installation and labour, and on-site service is not included. Liability for direct losses is capped at what you paid, with no indirect or consequential damages.
Check Dimplex Winslow SWM4820 on Amazon
Editor: Isaac Daniels
Touchstone Sideline 50 - 80004
Choose the Sideline 50 when you want an electric fireplace insert that sits flush in a wall. Touchstone lists it as 50 3/8 inches wide, 21 1/2 inches high and 5 1/2 inches deep, with a 45 by 12-inch fire area and a front heating vent so it can be flush mounted. It can also be wall-mounted, and it can be plugged in or hardwired at 120 V.
The coil wire heater with blower has a low setting of 750 W and a high setting of 1,500 W. Touchstone gives 400 square feet of room coverage and says the flame effect can be used without the heater. It lists three flame colors and a 10-color ember bed. The manual's box list is the fireplace, a wall bracket, six wood screws, six drywall anchors, a remote, a bag of crystal embers and a fire log; the product page says the remote's batteries are not included.
Touchstone's product page calls the 80004 a Smart fireplace that is Wi-Fi enabled and compatible with Amazon Alexa and Google Home, controlled by the included remote or Touchstone's Smart mobile app. The Sideline series manual, which covers several models, says Touchstone's WiFi-enabled fireplaces are powered by the Touchstone Fireplace app and have a WiFi symbol in the control panel area, but it does not say which models are WiFi-enabled. The 80004 brochure linked from the product page and the checked Amazon title do not mention Wi-Fi, so confirm on the listing before relying on smart features.
Conflicting figures: Fireplace weight is 59 lb on Touchstone's page, its brochure and the listing, but 46 lb in the manual; shipping weight is 62 lb on the page and 56 lb in the manual. Heat output is 5,000 BTU on the page and listing and 5118 BTUs in the brochure. The page lists 11 amperes and up; the manual lists 12 A. The brochure gives 50.4 × 8 × 25 inches, while the page and manual give 50 3/8 × 21 1/2 × 5 1/2 inches.
Warranty: The manual warrants Touchstone electric fireplaces against defects in material and workmanship for one year from date of purchase, and Touchstone will repair or replace any fireplace or part that is deemed defective or becomes defective during normal use within that year. Electrical components (fan motor, heater motor, control board, remote control and control panel) are covered for one year, and replacement parts are free of charge during the first year.
Replacement parts and units are covered for 90 days or the rest of the original one-year warranty, whichever is greater. The product page describes the standard one-year warranty as replacement of any non-functioning electronic parts plus free phone tech support. Not covered: damage caused by third parties; misuse, alterations, accident, lack of maintenance, abuse or neglect; paint scratches, cosmetic blemishes, dents, corrosion or other normal wear and tear; damage from water, weather, long periods of dampness, condensation, or damaging chemicals or cleaners; and breakage of the glass panel.
Parts installed from other manufacturers, or outdoor use, void it. Touchstone is not responsible for installation, labor or other expenses of reinstalling a warranted part, and labor costs for warranty replacement parts are the owner's responsibility. The manual says extended coverage is available by contacting Touchstone at 1-800-215-1990, and it does not say who pays shipping.
Check Touchstone Sideline 80004 on Amazon
Real Flame Malie - 13057E-VGY
Choose the Malie when you want a complete fireplace mantel rather than recessing or wall-mounting a unit; its anti-topple bracket still fastens to the wall. The Venetian Gray 13057E-VGY measures 67.25 by 14 by 37.5 inches, with a 39 by 5.75 by 18.25-inch firebox, and weighs 133 lb assembled. Real Flame lists 120 V, 1,500 W and 12.6 amps, 5,100 BTU, and supplemental heat for rooms up to 1,000 square feet. It plugs into a standard three-prong outlet.
Real Flame lists the mantel, an electric firebox, a remote, a 6-foot power cord with lay-flat plug, an anti-topple device, hardware and the manual as included, and lists an automatic safety shut-off device. Assembly is required and it ships in two boxes. In the mantel manual, the 4192 electric firebox goes in from the rear of the mantel and attaches with four supplied screws, and the anti-topple bracket is secured to a wall stud or, if no stud is accessible, the included drywall anchors.
Real Flame sells the Malie SMART, SKU 13057ES-VGY, as a separate product controlled by its Bluetooth Smart Tech App, touchscreen or remote. Check that the listing code reads 13057E-VGY if you want this version. Real Flame says the mantel supports up to 30 lb and not to place a TV on it.
Warranty: Real Flame's product page lists a 1-year limited warranty on the electric firebox and mantel; the mantel manual lists the body at 1 year limited, and the firebox's own manual was not read. The mantel manual warrants against manufacturing defects in material and workmanship after correct assembly and under normal use and proper maintenance, from the date of purchase.
It is non-transferable and covers the original purchaser only, provided the purchase was made through an authorized Real Flame dealer. It covers functionality, not cosmetic issues such as scratches, dents, rust, oxidation, corrosion, areas discolored or cracked by prolonged exposure to extreme heat, or damage from abrasive or chemical cleaners; if parts deteriorate to the point of non-performance within the warranty period, Real Flame will provide a replacement part.
It excludes damage from shipping, improper assembly, installation or storage, installation that does not comply with building codes or is not in accordance with the included manual, abuse, lack of maintenance, hostile environments, accident, natural weather and unworkmanlike repairs. Modification, fuels other than those approved by Real Flame, or parts from other manufacturers nullify it.
Keep your receipt: Real Flame requires reasonable proof of the purchase date, will not replace parts without proof of purchase, must have the opportunity to verify the defect, and requires troubleshooting with Customer Service (1-800-654-1704) before internal components are covered. Real Flame chooses to replace the component, replace the product or give a refund; it is not responsible for installation, labor or other reinstallation costs or for incidental or consequential damages, and any implied warranty is limited to the warranty period.
The manual asks owners to register at realflame.com/registration for recall notifications, proof of ownership and quality assurance. The checked listing's warranty field only refers to the product description.
Check Real Flame Malie 13057E-VGY on Amazon
Dr. Infrared Heater - DR-991
Choose the DR-991 for a fireplace-style heater that stands on the floor; Dr. Infrared says its freestanding design requires no complicated installation. It lists the heater at 14.2 by 14.2 by 36.8 inches and under 20 lb with a 6-foot cord, and calls it easy to move. It has a 1,500 W infrared heater for a standard 120 V outlet. The manual's parts list is three legs and three screws, and each leg fastens to the heater with one of the included screws.
It adds a built-in humidifier. The manual says you must use distilled water, that the humidifier stops and its LED turns red when no water is detected, and not to lift the water tank by the mist lid. Dr. Infrared also lists a 3D flame effect with two brightness levels, a thermostat (the manual gives 30°F to 99°F in Auto mode), tip-over and overheat protection, ETL certification, and a remote that takes two AAA batteries, not included.
Dr. Infrared gives no room size or BTU figure on the product page or in the manual, and the manual lists no amp rating. The manual says a slight trace of smoke or odor is normal when the unit is first operated.
Conflicting descriptions: Dr. Infrared's product page lists the heat settings as Auto, High and Low in three places and as ECO, High and Low in another; the manual lists Auto mode and manual Hi and Lo. The page describes a 12-hour timer; the manual gives an ON timer of 0 to 12 hours and an OFF timer of 0 to 24 hours.
Warranty: The manual gives a one-year limited component warranty; the product page says a full year of coverage against defects in materials and workmanship, with support to repair, replace or resolve the problem. Dr. Heater USA's warranty information page, which covers its heaters in general, says that to activate the warranty you register the unit by mailing back the Warranty Form or filling out the online Warranty Registration form (the manual gives DrHeaterUSA.com/register-your-heater).
To keep the warranty in effect, the heater must be used and handled as directed in the instruction manual and used with the equipment specified on the product box, and it does not cover damage caused by accident, misuse, abuse or negligence. Neither the manual nor the warranty page states a proof-of-purchase requirement or who pays shipping. Check the troubleshooting tips at DrHeaterUSA.com, then call the service center at 1-800-317-1688.
Check Dr. Infrared DR-991 on Amazon
Common buying questions
Do electric fireplaces give off heat?
These four do. Dimplex rates the SWM4820 at 1,400 W and 5,000 BTU, Touchstone rates the 80004 at 750 W low and 1,500 W high, Real Flame rates the Malie at 1,500 W and 5,100 BTU, and Dr. Infrared rates the DR-991 at 1,500 W. Dimplex and Touchstone also say their flames can run without heat.
Do electric fireplaces use a lot of electricity?
Compare the rated draw. The Dimplex is 1,400 W and 12 A; the Touchstone is 1,500 W max and 12 A in its manual (11 amperes and up on its page); the Real Flame is 1,500 W and 12.6 amps; the DR-991 is 1,500 W with no amp figure given. The Touchstone also has a 750 W low setting.
Can I put a TV on an electric fireplace mantel?
Not on the Malie: Real Flame says its mantel supports up to 30 lb and not to place a TV on it. For the Sideline 80004, Touchstone recommends placement 8 inches below a mounted flat-screen TV.
What does an electric fireplace insert need in the wall?
For the Touchstone 80004, a rough opening 47 1/8 inches wide, 20 1/2 inches high and 5 3/4 inches deep in a non-load-bearing wall; its manual says never to install it into load-bearing walls. It can be plugged in or hardwired at 120 V.
Which of these models needs no wall mounting?
The DR-991 is freestanding: Dr. Infrared says it requires no complicated installation, and its three legs fasten on with the included screws. The Dimplex can also sit on a table with its included stand. The Malie needs assembly, and its anti-topple bracket fastens to a wall stud or the included drywall anchors.