Prepared October 18, 2026 from All-Clad and Circulon product pages, and the exact Amazon listings. These picks are built from the makers' published specs and manuals.
Choose by heat, size and lid
Pick by the biggest bird or roast you cook, how hot you roast, and whether you want a lid.
Nonstick steel pan with chrome-plated U-rack; oven to 450 F; hand wash recommended.
Lower oven limit; Circulon lists no turkey size.
Check heat limits, stovetop use and care
Oven heat: All-Clad lists 500 F for the 13 x 16 roaster with a 375 F rack, and 600 F oven and broiler use for the oval roaster. Circulon lists 450 F.
Stovetop: All-Clad says the 13 x 16 roaster works on any stovetop except induction, and the oval roaster on any stovetop including induction.
Size: All-Clad says the 13 x 16 roaster holds turkeys up to 25 lb and the oval roaster takes roasts up to 20 lb.
Care: All-Clad lists both roasters as dishwasher safe and recommends silicone, nylon or wooden utensils for the nonstick one. Circulon says dishwasher safe, hand wash recommended.
Exact models and buying options
All-Clad Stainless Steel Large Roaster with Nonstick Rack, 13 x 16 inch
Choose this roaster for the Thanksgiving turkey. All-Clad says the 16 x 13 inch pan accommodates turkeys up to 25 lb, with a removable V-shaped rack that lifts the meat, and that the pan doubles as a baking dish with the rack out.
All-Clad lists heavy gauge stainless steel with a nonstick interior, upright stainless handles, oven use up to 500 degrees F for the roaster and 375 degrees F for the rack, any stovetop except induction, and dishwasher-safe care. All-Clad says it contains PTFE for the nonstick. Model E751S264, UPC 011644910006, matching the Amazon listing; made in China.
Skip it when: You cook on induction or roast above 375 F with the rack in.
Warranty: All-Clad's page lists a Limited Lifetime Warranty.
All-Clad Stainless Steel Oval Roaster with Flat Rack and Lid, 15 inch
Choose the oval roaster for ham, brisket and covered roasts. All-Clad says it fits large cuts up to 20 lb, its high domed lid helps keep meat moist, and its high sides reduce splattering, with a stainless flat rack inside.
All-Clad lists heavy gauge polished stainless steel with a bonded base, oven and broiler use up to 600 degrees F, any stovetop including induction, and dishwasher-safe care. The set is the roaster, lid and flat rack. Model E7879964, UPC 011644904289, matching the Amazon listing; made in China.
Skip it when: Your turkey is over 20 lb (see the 13 x 16 roaster).
Warranty: All-Clad's page lists a Limited Lifetime Warranty.
Choose the Circulon roaster when easy food release matters more than high heat. Circulon lists heavy-duty steel construction, a nonstick interior and exterior, wire handles and a chrome-plated U-shaped rack that keeps food off the bottom of the pan.
Circulon lists oven use up to 450 degrees F and says the pan is dishwasher safe with hand washing recommended. Item 56539, barcode 051153565397, which the Amazon listing carries.
Skip it when: You roast hotter than 450 F or want a stated turkey capacity.
Warranty: Circulon's page lists a Limited Lifetime Warranty.
All-Clad 13 x 16 roaster and 15 inch oval roaster: Limited Lifetime Warranty on All-Clad's pages. Circulon nonstick roaster: Limited Lifetime Warranty on Circulon's page. Read each maker's warranty terms for what is covered.
Common buying questions
What size roasting pan do I need for a turkey?
All-Clad says its 13 x 16 inch roaster accommodates turkeys up to 25 lb, and rates its 15 inch oval roaster for roasts up to 20 lb.
Can a roasting pan go on the stovetop for gravy?
All-Clad lists its 13 x 16 roaster for any stovetop except induction, and its oval roaster for any stovetop including induction.
Is a nonstick roasting pan oven safe?
Yes, within limits: Circulon lists 450 F for its nonstick roaster, and All-Clad lists 500 F for its nonstick-interior roaster with the rack limited to 375 F.
Do I need a roasting pan with a lid?
All-Clad says the oval roaster's domed lid helps keep meats moist; the open 13 x 16 and Circulon roasters come with racks but no lid.
All-Clad and Circulon product pages supply the specifications. These picks are built from the makers' published specs and manuals.
All-Clad: Stainless Steel Nonstick Large Roaster with Rack, 13 x 16 inch (E751S264) (all-clad.com), Stainless Steel Oval Roaster with Flat Rack and Lid, 15 inch (E7879964) (all-clad.com).
Circulon: Roasting Pan with Rack: Nonstick Roaster (56539) (circulon.com).
Check the exact model, what is in the box, seller and return notice before ordering. Product details can change.