As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How this site earns
KEEN Cincinnati 90°, carbon toe
Product photo: Amazon
Short answer
My top pick is the KEEN Cincinnati 90° Heel, with a carbon toe, EH and F3445 slip ratings, a waterproof liner and a Goodyear welt. Get the Irish Setter Ashby for hot asphalt or roofs, or the Thorogood for a USA-made boot.
All six were new and in stock at my 7:07 AM check on Oct 22. Each is a men’s 6 in. lace-up boot with an ASTM F2413 safety toe, checked on the same five ratings.
1Product photo: Amazon
Best for wet sites and ladders
KEEN Cincinnati 90°
Cincinnati 90°, Coffee Bean/Black, 10 D
Buy it ifYou work on wet ground or ladders and want the most complete set of published safety ratings here.
Skip it ifYou walk on hot asphalt or roofing. The Ashby states a 475°F sole.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
The six picks, card by card
Best for wet sites and ladders
KEEN Cincinnati 90°
The Cincinnati is my top pick. It was new and in stock at my 7:07 AM check on Oct 22, sold by Amazon.com. The listing names model 1032622, and KEEN’s own page for the Cincinnati 6″ Waterproof 90° Heel Boot (Carbon Toe) carries the same number.
The safety toes are carbon, with separate left and right shapes. KEEN says they weigh 15% less than steel and give a lower-profile fit. The listing gives the ratings as ASTM F2413 M I/75 C/75 EH, plus ASTM F3445 for slip.
F3445 is ASTM’s newer slip-resistance standard, the newest slip standard named here. The listing adds ASTM F1677 Mark II, an older slip test, and SATRA TM31 for outsole abrasion. The rubber outsole is oil- and slip-resistant and non-marking.
Waterproofing is KEEN.DRY, a breathable membrane liner that KEEN says lets vapor out without letting water in. The listing adds a mesh liner that works with the membrane. That matches the Boondock and the Ariat.
The sole is stitched on with a continuous Goodyear welt, which KEEN tags as KEEN.WELT. Thorogood’s repair page says soles held on mainly with glue are the usual exception when a cobbler resoles boots, so a welt keeps that door open. KEEN itself doesn’t mention resoling.
The 90° heel gives the boot its name. KEEN says it adds stability and grip on soft ground, ladders and other uneven surfaces, and the listing says it helps catch or lock your foot in place. The listing gives the heel as 5/8 in.; KEEN’s product tags say 1/2 in.
The leather is KEEN’s barnyard-resistant full grain, which the listing says resists oleic acid, urea, sodium chloride and ammonium hydroxide. Cushioning is KEEN’s Luftcell, an air-infused midsole. KEEN tags the outsole as heat resistant but gives no temperature, so its heat claim has no figure to compare.
KEEN sells it in men’s 7 to 15, regular and wide. My call: the most complete set of published ratings here, for wet ground and ladder work.
Pros
ASTM F3445 slip and F2413 EH ratings
KEEN.DRY waterproof membrane
Continuous Goodyear welt
90° heel for ladders and soft ground
Sizes 7 to 15, regular and wide
Cons
No heat temperature stated
Heel height differs by source
Weight not stated
Resoling not mentioned by KEEN
Listing is one size; pick yours on Amazon
Buy it if
You work on wet ground or ladders and want the most complete set of published safety ratings here.
Skip it if
You walk on hot asphalt or roofing. The Ashby states a 475°F sole.
Best for wet, messy floors
Timberland Boondock
The Boondock comes second and is the only pick whose waterproof liner carries a second rating. It was new and in stock at my 7:07 AM check on Oct 22, sold by Amazon.com. The listing names style TB1A1FZP001, which matches Timberland’s page for the Boondock 6″ Composite Toe Waterproof Work Boot.
Timberland says its membrane is waterproof and breathable and resists blood-borne pathogens as defined by ASTM F1671. That matters if your work puts fluids on your boots, and no other pick here names that test.
The toe is an asymmetrical composite cap that meets the ASTM F2413 impact and compression tests. In front of it sits a molded rubber toe protector that Timberland says is as thick as a standard boot outsole.
Timberland names EH protection to ASTM F2413 and F2892. Its SR icon, which the Boondock page shows, means the boot meets the slip requirements of F2413, F2892 or F3445 when tested to F2913. Both ratings are stated in full.
The build is a mix: a three-quarter Goodyear welt with a cemented heel, in Timberland’s words. That sits between a full welt and a cement build, because part of the sole is glued.
The outsole is Timberland’s All-Weather TPU, which it says stays flexible in changing weather and grips wet and frosted ice surfaces. The description calls it heat-, slip-, oil- and abrasion-resistant but gives no temperature.
Inside are Anti-Fatigue Technology polyurethane footbeds, OrthoLite insoles and a fiberglass shank, with a rigid external heel cup for side-to-side support. Timberland gives 2.43 lb for a men’s size 9, says the boot is imported, and sells it in medium and wide.
My call: the pick for wet, messy floors where a pathogen-resistant liner counts. The part-cement build and the missing heat figure are its tradeoffs.
Pros
Membrane rated to ASTM F1671 for blood-borne pathogens
EH to ASTM F2413 and F2892
SR slip rating
Molded rubber toe protector
Medium and wide widths
Cons
Part welt, part cement build
No heat temperature stated
Imported, per Timberland
Resoling not mentioned by Timberland
Listing is one size; pick yours on Amazon
Buy it if
Your work puts water or body fluids on your boots, and you want a liner rated for both.
Skip it if
You want a fully stitched sole. The KEEN has a full Goodyear welt.
Best for a waterproof moc toe
Ariat Rebar Lift
The Rebar Lift sits just behind the Boondock and is the only waterproof pick with a stated heat figure. It was new and in stock at my 7:07 AM check on Oct 22, sold by Amazon.com. The listing names style 10046876, which matches Ariat’s Rebar Lift 6″ Waterproof Composite Toe page.
Ariat lists ASTM F2413 for the composite toe, for EH and for slip resistance, and rates the boot I/C EH SRO. Its page says the boot meets ASTM’s highest standards for slip resistance. Both ratings are stated in full.
Waterproofing is Ariat’s DRYShield, a waterproof, breathable build. The listing describes it as waterproof full-grain leathers with an impermeable barrier, and Ariat says it helps keep feet dry on wet or muddy ground.
The sole is SMARTLITE TPU from Huntsman, oil- and slip-resisting. The listing says it passes the hot contact test at 150°C, or 302°F. That’s a stated temperature, though it’s lower than the Ashby’s 475°F.
It’s the only cement-built pick, per the listing, which means the sole is bonded rather than stitched. The cement build is the main thing holding it back. Thorogood’s repair page names glued soles as the usual exception when cobblers resole boots.
Like the KEEN, it has a 90° heel, which Ariat says gives secure footing on ladders, rungs and uneven surfaces. Ariat gives a 6 in. shaft, a 1.25 in. heel and a round moc toe.
Comfort parts are Ariat’s ATS support, a FLX Foam midsole and a removable All Day Cushioning insole. The upper is full-grain leather from Leather Working Group-certified tanneries, with a 50% recycled polyester lining. Ariat sells D and EE widths.
My call: a waterproof moc toe with a stated heat rating and a ladder heel. The cement build is its main tradeoff.
Pros
Hot contact test at 302°F (listing)
DRYShield waterproof build
ASTM F2413 EH and slip ratings
90° heel for ladders and rungs
D and EE widths
Cons
Cement build, the only one here
Lower heat figure than the Ashby
Weight not stated
Resoling harder on a glued sole
Listing is one size; pick yours on Amazon
Buy it if
You want a waterproof moc toe with a ladder heel and a stated outsole heat rating.
Skip it if
You want a boot a cobbler can resole. The Ashby is welted and its maker says resoleable.
Best for hot asphalt and roofs
Irish Setter Ashby
The Ashby is the heat pick and the only aluminum toe here. It was new and in stock at my 7:07 AM check on Oct 22, sold by a third-party seller. The listing names model 83652, which matches Irish Setter’s page for the Ashby men’s 6-inch leather safety toe boot.
Irish Setter says roofers and paving contractors often work in high heat, and the Ashby’s HRO outsole is heat resistant to melting at a minimum of 475°F. That’s the highest outsole temperature any maker states on this page.
Irish Setter’s spec table lists ASTM F2413-24 I/C, EH and SR. The listing gives ASTM F2413-18 M/I/C EH and ASTM F3445-21 SR instead. Either way, EH and slip are both named in full.
The toe cap is aluminum. Irish Setter doesn’t give a weight saving over steel, so I don’t claim one. The outsole is its rubber-EVA Traction Tred.
Construction is Goodyear welt, and Irish Setter answers “Resoleable: Yes” in its spec table. It’s one of two picks whose maker says so. The listing adds that the welt helps keep water out of the boot.
It’s water resistant, not waterproof: the listing title says water resistant, and Irish Setter names no membrane. Water resistance is the Ashby’s one weak point. Pick a waterproof boot if you stand in water.
Inside is a removable polyurethane footbed over a Texon insole, on Irish Setter’s 325 last. The leather is oiled full grain. Irish Setter lists a weight of 3 lb 6 oz without saying for what size, sizes 7 to 14 in D or EE, and global sourcing.
Irish Setter is a Red Wing Shoe Co. brand, per its site footer. Its own store sells the same boot in a soft-toe version, style 83605, which isn’t a safety boot; check the model number on Amazon before you buy.
My call: the boot for hot asphalt and roofs. Its tradeoff is water resistance short of waterproof.
Pros
HRO sole rated to at least 475°F
Goodyear welt; maker says resoleable
EH and SR ratings
Aluminum safety toe
D and EE, sizes 7 to 14
Cons
Water resistant, not waterproof
Sold by a third-party seller, not Amazon
Globally sourced
ASTM edition differs by source
Listing is one size; pick yours on Amazon
Buy it if
You work on hot asphalt or roofing, or you want a welted boot its maker says can be resoled.
Skip it if
You stand in water. The KEEN and Ariat are waterproof.
Best for dry sites, steel toe
Timberland Pit Boss
The Pit Boss was the top pick on the old page. It was new and in stock at my 7:07 AM check on Oct 22, sold by Amazon.com. The listing names style TB133032001, which matches Timberland’s Pit Boss 6″ Steel Toe Work Boot page.
The toe is an asymmetrical steel cap. The listing gives ASTM F2413-18 I and C, and EH to ASTM F2413-18 and F2892-18. Timberland’s page shows its SR slip icon too, so EH and slip are both named.
The outsole is Timberland PRO rubber, which the listing calls heat resistant, with slip, oil and abrasion resistance. Timberland’s description says the same and adds non-marking. No temperature is given.
The sole is Goodyear welted; Timberland calls it a durable mechanical bond. That’s a full Goodyear welt, the same as the KEEN, the Ashby and the Thorogood.
It isn’t waterproof. Timberland makes no waterproof claim for the Pit Boss, and the upper is nubuck leather. It has no waterproofing, and that is why it sits fifth.
Comfort is Timberland’s 24/7 Comfort Suspension system, which it says supports the arch and cushions every step, plus a contoured shock-diffusion plate and a padded top collar. The lining is ReBOTL fabric with at least 50% recycled plastic and an antimicrobial treatment.
Timberland gives 2.83 lb for a men’s size 9. That’s 0.4 lb more than the Boondock at the same size, and the only like-for-like weight pair on this page, since both figures come from the same maker for the same size.
Timberland lists it as imported. I didn’t read a size or width range for the Pit Boss, so check the listing’s size menu for yours; the Boondock and KEEN both come in wide.
My call: a steel-toe welted boot for dry sites. No waterproofing is its main tradeoff.
Pros
Steel toe to ASTM F2413-18 I and C
EH and SR ratings
Goodyear welt
24/7 Comfort Suspension system
Sold by Amazon.com
Cons
Not waterproof
No heat temperature stated
Imported, per Timberland
Sizes and widths not read
Listing is one size; pick yours on Amazon
Buy it if
You work on dry sites and want a welted steel-toe boot sold by Amazon.
Skip it if
Your site is wet. The Boondock is Timberland’s waterproof pick here.
Best for a USA-made boot
Thorogood 804-4375
The American Heritage 804-4375 is the one pick made in the USA. It was new and in stock at my 7:07 AM check on Oct 22, sold by a third-party seller. The listing names 804-4375, which matches Thorogood’s page for the American Heritage 6″ Trail Crazy Horse safety toe moc toe.
Thorogood says it’s made in the USA with USA and globally sourced components, from American leathers. The leather is Trail Crazy Horse full grain, which the listing says has a wax applied for an older look.
The toe is steel, rated to ASTM F2413-18 with EH, per the listing. The MAXWear 90 outsole has a heel and, the listing says, meets ASTM F3445-21 for slip. Thorogood’s own page calls it slip-resistant.
Construction is a Goodyear storm welt. Thorogood says that means you can re-sole the boots over the years, and its repair page points owners to cobblers. Note its warning: work by an outside cobbler voids Thorogood’s warranty.
Thorogood’s spec table says non-waterproof, unlined and non-insulated, and it names no heat-resistant outsole. Those two gaps are why it sits last of the six.
Comfort parts are a removable Ultimate Shock Absorption footbed on a Poron comfort cushion insole, and a composite shank. Thorogood says boots in the American Heritage line need no break-in time.
Sizes run 7 to 14 in D and EE. Thorogood’s warranty is one year against defects, and only for boots bought from an authorized seller with a receipt. Ask the Amazon seller whether it’s authorized if the warranty matters to you.
The listing names carpenters, electricians, pipefitters, plumbers, welders and HVAC workers among the trades it’s built for. Its “job-fitted” design, in Thorogood’s phrase, is meant for outdoor and industrial work.
My call: the moc toe for buyers who want a USA-made, resoleable boot. Its tradeoffs are no waterproofing and no heat claim.
Pros
Made in USA with USA and global parts
Goodyear storm welt; maker says resoleable
ASTM F3445-21 slip (listing)
EH rated
D and EE, sizes 7 to 14
Cons
Not waterproof, unlined
No heat claim
Sold by a third-party seller, not Amazon
Warranty needs an authorized seller
Outside resoles void the warranty
Buy it if
You want a moc-toe boot made in the USA that a cobbler can resole.
Skip it if
You work in the wet or on hot surfaces. The Ariat is a waterproof moc toe with a heat rating.
Which boot matches your job?
Tick what your workday involves. The finder keeps only the picks whose makers state that feature.
Boot finder
Every pick has an ASTM safety toe and an EH rating. Tick the conditions you work in.
All six picks match. Tick what your job involves to narrow them down.
Features as stated on the makers’ pages and the Amazon listings, read Oct 22, 2026.
The finder reads only what the makers publish. A boot that leaves a box unticked may still do the job; its maker just doesn’t say so. The ratings chart below shows each rating in full.
The six picks compared
From the makers’ pages and the Amazon listings. Scroll sideways on a phone; tap a header to sort on a computer.
All six are men’s 6 in. lace-up boots with an ASTM F2413 safety toe and an EH rating. They differ in toe material, waterproofing, how the sole is attached and whether the outsole has a stated heat rating.
Safety ratings side by side
Every rating the makers publish for these six boots, in one chart.
Pick
Toe cap
EH
Slip
Waterproof
Build
Heat
KEEN Cincinnati
carbon toe
EH
ASTM F3445 slip
waterproof membrane
Goodyear welt
heat-resistant claim with no temperature
Timberland Boondock
composite toe
EH
SR slip rating
waterproof membrane
three-quarter Goodyear welt with cement heel
heat-resistant claim
Ariat Rebar Lift
composite toe
EH
SR
DRYShield waterproof
cement build
hot contact test at 302 degrees F
Irish Setter Ashby
aluminum toe
EH
ASTM F3445 slip
water resistant
Goodyear welt
heat resistant to 475 degrees F
Timberland Pit Boss
steel toe
EH
SR
not waterproof
Goodyear welt
heat-resistant claim
Thorogood 804-4375
steel toe
EH
ASTM F3445 slip
not waterproof
Goodyear storm welt
no heat claim
The first three columns are a clean sweep: every pick names a safety toe, an EH rating and a slip rating. The differences sit in the last three. Three boots are waterproof, four are fully welted, and only two give an outsole temperature.
Steel, aluminum or composite toe
Every safety toe here meets the same ASTM F2413 impact and compression tests. The material changes the weight and whether the cap is metal.
Toe cap
Picks
What the makers say
Steel
Pit Boss, Thorogood
Metallic, asymmetrical cap (Timberland listing); ASTM F2413-18 (both)
Is steel toe or composite toe better? On protection, the makers give the same answer: each cap meets ASTM F2413 for impact and compression. KEEN is the only maker here that puts a number on the weight difference, 15% lighter than steel for its carbon toe.
A non-metal cap matters if your site has metal detectors, but the cap is only one part. Eyelets and shanks can be metal too, and none of these makers calls its whole boot metal-free.
What an EH rating means
EH stands for electrical hazard. All six picks carry it, so it decides nothing between them, but it’s worth knowing what it covers.
Pick
EH rating as stated
Source
KEEN Cincinnati 90°
ASTM F2413 M I/75 C/75 EH
Listing
Timberland Boondock
ASTM F2413 and F2892, tested to F2412
Timberland
Ariat Rebar Lift
ASTM F2413, EH
Ariat
Irish Setter Ashby
ASTM F2413-24 I/C, EH
Irish Setter
Timberland Pit Boss
ASTM F2413-18 and F2892-18
Listing
Thorogood 804-4375
ASTM F2413-18, EH
Listing, Thorogood
Timberland defines EH as secondary underfoot protection against live electrical circuits, energized conductors, parts or apparatus. Secondary is the key word: it backs up other measures. OSHA’s footwear rule, 29 CFR 1910.136, lists electrical hazards that remain after an employer takes other protective steps as one reason protective footwear is required.
If your employer issues a footwear spec, match the letters on the boot’s label to it.
Slip ratings, SR and ASTM F3445
Every pick names a slip rating, but they name different ones.
Pick
Slip rating as stated
Outsole
KEEN Cincinnati 90°
ASTM F3445; also F1677 Mark II
Rubber, oil- and slip-resistant, non-marking
Timberland Boondock
SR: F2413, F2892 or F3445 via F2913
All-Weather TPU
Ariat Rebar Lift
ASTM F2413 slip resistant, SRO
SMARTLITE TPU
Irish Setter Ashby
SR (Irish Setter); F3445-21 (listing)
Rubber-EVA Traction Tred
Timberland Pit Boss
SR icon
Timberland PRO rubber
Thorogood 804-4375
ASTM F3445-21 (listing)
MAXWear 90 with heel
Timberland’s definition is the clearest one any maker gives here: SR means a boot meets the slip-resistance requirements of ASTM F2413, F2892 or F3445 when tested to ASTM F2913. F3445 is ASTM’s newer stand-alone slip standard, and three picks name it directly.
Slip grip wears with the tread. Thorogood’s repair page lists less traction than usual, or starting to slip, as a sign that boots need a new sole or replacing.
Waterproof, water resistant or neither
Three picks are waterproof, one is water resistant and two make no water claim.
Pick
Water claim
How the maker does it
KEEN Cincinnati 90°
Waterproof
KEEN.DRY breathable membrane liner
Timberland Boondock
Waterproof
Waterproof leather plus a breathable membrane, ASTM F1671
Ariat Rebar Lift
Waterproof
DRYShield waterproof, breathable build
Irish Setter Ashby
Water resistant
Listing title; welt helps keep water out
Timberland Pit Boss
None stated
Nubuck upper
Thorogood 804-4375
Non-waterproof
Unlined, per Thorogood
Timberland explains how it builds a waterproof boot: leathers sealed in tanning, then either sealed seams or an internal waterproof, breathable membrane, with gusseted tongues to stop water at the laces. KEEN and Ariat describe the same idea, a liner that keeps water out and lets vapor through.
Are waterproof work boots worth it? If you stand in water, mud or wet grass, yes. If you don’t, an unlined boot like the Thorogood skips the liner altogether. Thorogood suggests a leather waterproofing agent for boots that see moisture often.
Goodyear welt or cement construction
How the sole is attached decides whether a cobbler can replace it later.
Pick
Construction
Maker says resoleable?
KEEN Cincinnati 90°
Continuous Goodyear welt
Not stated
Timberland Boondock
¾ Goodyear welt, cement heel
Not stated
Ariat Rebar Lift
Cement
Not stated
Irish Setter Ashby
Goodyear welt
Yes
Timberland Pit Boss
Goodyear welt
Not stated
Thorogood 804-4375
Goodyear storm welt
Yes
A welted boot has a strip of leather stitched around it, and the sole is stitched to that strip. A cement boot has its sole bonded on. Thorogood’s repair page says most work boots can be resoled, with glued-on soles the main exception, as long as the upper is intact and the insole hasn’t cracked.
There’s a catch for safety boots. ASTM F2413’s scope warns that resoling, or adding an aftermarket footbed or insert, could make a boot fail the standard and void its ASTM marking. Ask the cobbler, or your safety officer, before resoling a rated boot you need for work.
Heat-resistant outsoles
Five picks say their outsole resists heat. Only two put a temperature on it.
Pick
Heat claim
Temperature
Irish Setter Ashby
HRO: resistant to melting
At least 475°F
Ariat Rebar Lift
Passes the hot contact test
150°C (302°F)
KEEN Cincinnati 90°
Heat-resistant outsole (product tag)
Not stated
Timberland Boondock
Heat-resistant TPU (description)
Not stated
Timberland Pit Boss
Heat-resistant rubber (listing)
Not stated
Thorogood 804-4375
None
Not stated
Irish Setter writes the Ashby’s heat claim for roofers and paving contractors, who work on hot surfaces, and names 475°F as the minimum its HRO soles resist melting at. Ariat’s 302°F is a hot contact test figure from the listing.
A claim with no number can’t be compared with a stated figure. If your work is on fresh asphalt or a hot roof, pick a boot with a stated temperature.
Sizes, widths and weight
Each Amazon listing I link is one size and color. Choose your own size on the listing before you buy.
Pick
Sizes
Widths
Weight as stated
KEEN Cincinnati 90°
7 to 15
Regular, wide
Not stated
Timberland Boondock
Not read
Medium, wide
2.43 lb, men’s size 9
Ariat Rebar Lift
Not read
D, EE
Not stated
Irish Setter Ashby
7 to 14
D, EE
3 lb 6 oz, size not stated
Timberland Pit Boss
Not read
Not read
2.83 lb, men’s size 9
Thorogood 804-4375
7 to 14
D, EE
Not stated
How should work boots fit? Start with the maker’s own size chart, since each brand cuts its own last. Irish Setter, for one, names the Ashby’s last, 325. At least five of the six come in a wide fit, so you don’t have to size up for width.
Plan your insole before you buy. ASTM F2413 warns that adding an aftermarket footbed or insert to a safety-toe boot could void its rating. The Ariat, Ashby and Thorogood ship with removable footbeds, per their makers.
Cleaning, conditioning and when to replace
Thorogood publishes the plainest care steps of any maker here. They apply to any leather work boot.
Step
What Thorogood says
Clean
Warm soapy water and a clean rag; brush the welt with a toothbrush if dirt builds up there
Dry
Let the boots dry before you condition or waterproof them, so moisture isn’t trapped
Condition
Monthly for hard wear, rain or heat; every 3 to 6 months for light wear
Protect
Store boots indoors; add a waterproofing agent if they’re often wet
Replace or resole
When the tread wears unevenly, traction drops, or the welt frays or separates
How long do work boots last? No maker here gives a number of months, because it depends on the job and the care. Thorogood says one of the main reasons leather cracks is that it dries out, which is why it stresses cleaning and conditioning.
How do you break in work boots? Thorogood says its American Heritage boots need no break-in time. The other makers don’t publish a break-in period, so wear new boots around the house for a few evenings before a full shift and check for rubbing.
Work boot recalls
I searched CPSC’s recall list since 2018 on Oct 22, 2026, for every brand on this page and for “work boot”.
Search
Recalls found
KEEN
0
Timberland
0
Ariat
0
Irish Setter
0
Thorogood
0
“Work boot”
2, both other brands (below)
The two work boot recalls, both from January 2024, were western pull-on boots. Boot Royalty recalled about 3,200 Justin Keaven met guard boots, model SE4570, because some could be missing the metatarsal guard. H.H. Brown recalled about 2,360 Redeemer DH5379 boots because the sole wasn’t puncture-resistant.
Neither brand is on this page. Keep your order page and the boot’s model number so you can match it to any notice at cpsc.gov/recalls.
Where the sources disagree
Places where a maker’s page and its Amazon listing don’t match. I go by the maker, then the listing.
Topic
One source says
Another says
Go by
KEEN 90° heel height
5/8 in. (listing)
1/2 in. (KEEN product tags)
KEEN
Ashby ASTM edition
F2413-24 I/C EH SR (Irish Setter)
F2413-18 M/I/C EH, F3445-21 SR (listing)
Both; check the boot’s label
Thorogood shank
Composite (Thorogood)
Fiberglass (listing)
Thorogood
Boondock waterproof test
ASTM F1671 (Timberland)
ASTM F1671-07 (listing)
Same test; the listing adds the year
Ariat slip label
SR (Ariat ratings box)
SRO (Ariat feature list)
Both appear on Ariat’s page
The two Ashby sources name different editions of ASTM F2413. Check the label inside the boot for the edition your pair carries, and match the model number on the listing to the maker’s page before you buy.
Which work boot fits you?
Question
If yes
If no
Does your employer require a safety toe and EH?
Any pick
Any pick, or a soft-toe boot
Do you work in water, mud or wet grass?
KEEN, Boondock or Ariat
Any pick
Do you work on hot asphalt or roofs?
Ashby (475°F) or Ariat (302°F)
Any pick
Do you climb ladders or walk rebar?
KEEN or Ariat (90° heel)
Any pick
Do you want a boot you can resole?
Ashby or Thorogood
Any pick
Does your site have metal detectors?
KEEN, Boondock or Ariat (non-metal toe)
Any pick
Do you want a boot made in the USA?
Thorogood
Any pick
Start with what your employer requires, because that rules boots in or out. Then match the ground: wet sites want a waterproof liner, hot ones want a stated heat rating. Last, choose for comfort and life, like a ladder heel or a sole you can replace.
Kitting out for the job? My knee pad guide and tool bag guide cover the other gear you’ll carry and kneel on all day.
Questions people ask
What are the best work boots?
My top pick is the KEEN Cincinnati 90° Heel. It names a carbon safety toe, EH, ASTM F3445 slip resistance, a KEEN.DRY waterproof liner and a Goodyear welt. The Irish Setter Ashby is the pick for hot surfaces.
Are steel toe or composite toe boots better?
Both meet the same ASTM F2413 impact and compression tests. Composite and carbon caps are non-metallic, and KEEN says its carbon toe weighs 15% less than steel. Steel caps are what the Pit Boss and Thorogood use.
What does EH mean on work boots?
Electrical hazard. Timberland defines it as secondary underfoot protection against live circuits and energized parts. Every pick on this page carries an EH rating.
What is ASTM F2413?
ASTM’s performance specification for protective footwear. It sets minimum requirements, and its scope warns that resoling or adding an aftermarket insert could void the marking. OSHA’s footwear rule cites it.
How should work boots fit?
Use each maker’s own size chart, since lasts differ by brand. Five of my six picks come in a wide width, and the KEEN runs to size 15. Plan insoles first, because ASTM warns aftermarket inserts could void a safety rating.
How do you break in work boots?
Thorogood says its American Heritage boots need no break-in time. The other makers here don’t publish a break-in period, so wear new boots for short stretches at home before a full shift.
How do you clean work boots?
Thorogood’s steps: wash off dirt with warm soapy water and a rag, brush the welt, let them dry, then rub in leather conditioner and wipe off the excess. Leave them overnight before relacing.
How long do work boots last?
No maker here gives a lifespan. Thorogood lists the signs to resole or replace: tread worn unevenly, less traction than usual, or a welt that’s fraying or pulling away from the sole.
Are Timberland PRO boots good work boots?
Both Timberland PRO picks are in the six. The Boondock has a waterproof, pathogen-resistant liner, and the Pit Boss has no waterproofing.
What work boots are made in the USA?
On this page, only the Thorogood American Heritage 804-4375, which Thorogood says is made in the USA with USA and globally sourced parts. Timberland lists both its boots as imported, and Irish Setter says the Ashby is globally sourced.
How much do work boots cost?
Prices move often, so each card shows today’s Amazon price with the time I read it. The Thorogood and Ashby are sold by a third-party seller; the other four are sold by Amazon itself.
How I pick work boots
How I pick
I looked at one kind of product: men’s 6 in. lace-up work boots with an ASTM F2413 safety toe. Six boots from five makers are picks.
Every pick passed an offer read on Amazon at 7:07 AM on Oct 22, 2026: new, in stock and the buy-box winner. I matched each listing to the maker’s page by model or style number.
Ratings come from KEEN, Timberland, Ariat, Irish Setter and Thorogood, and from the Amazon listings where the maker is silent. Nothing here is taken from customer reviews.
Why trust me
I’m Isaac Daniels, and I own and edit Plain Buy Guides. Picks are built from the makers' specs, manuals, and safety-agency guidance. I read each maker’s product page, ASTM’s F2413 scope, OSHA’s footwear rule and Thorogood’s care, repair and warranty pages on Oct 22, 2026. Where a maker and its listing disagree, I show both. A CPSC search found no recalls for any brand here.
Sources
KEEN Utility (keenfootwear.com), Men’s Cincinnati 6″ Waterproof 90° Heel Boot (Carbon Toe), product page and product data
Timberland (timberland.com), Timberland PRO Boondock 6″ Composite Toe Waterproof and Pit Boss 6″ Steel Toe pages and feature definitions
Ariat (ariat.com), Rebar Lift 6″ Waterproof Composite Toe Work Boot, style 10046876