Dogtra PATHFINDER2 GPS Tracking and E-Collar System vs Garmin Alpha TT 25 Dog Tracking and Training Collar (010-02447-20)
These are side-by-side facts taken from each product guide: published specifications, strengths and caveats as their sources state them. This page is not a test, a ranking or a verdict about which model is better.
Check Dogtra PATHFINDER2 GPS Tracking and E-Collar System on AmazonCheck Garmin Alpha TT 25 Dog Tracking and Training Collar (010-02447-20) on Amazon
Dogtra PATHFINDER2 GPS Tracking and E-Collar System
Owners of dogs of 35 pounds and up, with a 12.5 inch or larger neck, who want phone-based tracking and training with no subscription
The PATHFINDER2 (manual models PT20U and PR20U) pairs a 6.6 ounce GPS e-collar with a GPS connector that links to Dogtra's free app on your phone. Dogtra states offline maps, a 2-second update rate, up to 21 dogs and up to 9 miles line-of-sight range, with no monthly fee. It fits dogs from 35 pounds with a 12.5 inch neck, and the manual lists IPX9K.
Published specifications
- Maker: models PT20U and PR20U; smartphone and app required
- Maker: up to 9 mi line of sight; 2-second GPS update; up to 21 dogs
- Maker: receiver 6.6 oz, 3.4 x 1.5 x 1.7 in; 1 x 30 in Biothane strap
- Maker: minimum 35 lb and 12.5 in neck
- Maker: IPX9K; 3.5-hour charge; charge only at 32F to 113F
- Maker: 1 year plus 1 year extended warranty via authorized dealers
Strengths
- No subscription and offline maps, per Dogtra
- Up to 9 miles line of sight and up to 21 dogs on one system
- Three fence modes, two of which only notify
Caveats
- Needs a smartphone, ideally within 33 feet of the connector
- Not compatible with the original PATHFINDER system or app
- Phone requirements differ between Dogtra's page and its manual
Read the full Dogtra PATHFINDER2 GPS Tracking and E-Collar System guide
Garmin Alpha TT 25 Dog Tracking and Training Collar (010-02447-20)
Dog owners who have, or will buy, a compatible Garmin Alpha or Pro 550 Plus handheld
The Alpha TT 25 is Garmin's GPS and Galileo tracking and training collar, sold without a handheld. Garmin gives up to 9 miles of radio range and a battery life of 25 to 84 hours on the included pack depending on update rate, or 68 hours on the default dynamic rate. It has a 1 ATM water rating, takes collars up to 1 inch and updates over Wi-Fi while charging.
Published specifications
- Maker: up to 9 mi tracking and training range; VHF on the MURS band
- Maker: standard pack 68 hr dynamic, 25 hr at 2.5 s, 84 hr at 2 min
- Maker: extended pack (sold separately) 136, 50 and 168 hr respectively
- Maker: 1 ATM (10 m); operating -4F to 140F; charging 32F to 104F
- Maker: 3.2 x 1.8 x 1.4 in; 6.75 oz without strap, 9.26 oz with
- Maker: GPS and Galileo; multicolour LED; Wi-Fi updates while charging
Strengths
- Garmin publishes battery life at three update rates, not just a headline
- User-replaceable battery, with an extended pack sold separately
- Radio link to the handheld, with no subscription described
Caveats
- Collar only: a compatible Garmin handheld must be bought separately
- At the 2.5 second update rate the standard pack gives only 25 hours
- Listing says plastic contact points and 1.3 oz; Garmin says metal and 9.26 oz
Read the full Garmin Alpha TT 25 Dog Tracking and Training Collar (010-02447-20) guide
How to choose between them
Choose the Dogtra PATHFINDER2 GPS Tracking and E-Collar System if your situation matches: Owners of dogs of 35 pounds and up, with a 12.5 inch or larger neck, who want phone-based tracking and training with no subscription. Its main caveat: Needs a smartphone, ideally within 33 feet of the connector.
Choose the Garmin Alpha TT 25 Dog Tracking and Training Collar (010-02447-20) if your situation matches: Dog owners who have, or will buy, a compatible Garmin Alpha or Pro 550 Plus handheld. Its main caveat: Collar only: a compatible Garmin handheld must be bought separately.
Both entries repeat what each guide records. Confirm the model, included parts and availability on the current listing before ordering.
Primary sources
- Dogtra product page for the PATHFINDER2 Source for Dogtra PATHFINDER2 GPS Tracking and E-Collar System
- Dogtra PATHFINDER2 series Owner's Manual (PATHFINDER2 and PATHFINDER2 MINI) Source for Dogtra PATHFINDER2 GPS Tracking and E-Collar System
- Garmin product page for the Alpha TT 25 (part 010-02447-20), Specs and In the Box Source for Garmin Alpha TT 25 Dog Tracking and Training Collar (010-02447-20)
- Garmin Alpha TT 25 Owner's Manual: Dog Collar Device Specifications Source for Garmin Alpha TT 25 Dog Tracking and Training Collar (010-02447-20)
Primary sources checked .