As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Our product guides include affiliate links to Amazon.
Grass fertilizer: match the soil needs and lawn stage
For an established lawn where a feed with no phosphate in its labeled analysis fits the soil recommendations, compare Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Food 32-0-4. Milorganite 6-4-0 is a different, slow-release nitrogen option that contains phosphate. Scotts Starter 24-25-4 is for planting new grass where its nutrients are needed and permitted. Check soil guidance and local fertilizer restrictions before selecting a bag.
Checked October 14, 2026 against the named brand Amazon listings and primary sources below. We compared published specs and fit limits; picks are built from the makers' published specs and manuals.
Identify established turf versus seeding, sod or plugs.
Soil guidance
Match nutrient recommendations to the bag’s guaranteed analysis.
Local limits
Check permitted nutrients, timing, rates and water setbacks for your location.
Area and label
Measure actual lawn area and use the exact bag/spreader instructions.
Fertilizer analysis, bag weight and coverage are separate facts. We do not prescribe a universal application calendar, mix or spreader setting.
The picks, and why
Zero-phosphate analysis for established lawns: Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Food 22305, 12.5 pounds
Scotts’ current product page and issued 22305 label identify 32-0-4 fertilizer analysis and a 12.5-pound bag covering 5,000 square feet at the labeled rate. Choose it when that analysis matches the lawn’s nutrient plan. It is a different product from weed-and-feed or starter formulations.
The label says to use it on actively growing turf, avoid application near water or drains and when heavy rain is expected, and sweep stray product back from hard surfaces. Use the actual bag’s directions and local limits; coverage is not permission to apply on every date or site.
Product / bag
22305 /12.5 pounds
Analysis
32-0-4
Labeled coverage
5,000 square feet
Watch for: Read the current bag label, local timing/rate limits and soil recommendations. No burn-free, weed-killing or greening result is promised.
Milorganite’s maker page lists 6-4-0 analysis and a 32-pound bag with standard coverage of 2,500 square feet. The selected Amazon package adds a printed tips brochure. Milorganite describes its source as processed, kiln-dried material from Milwaukee’s wastewater-treatment microbes.
Its maker says state and local restrictions can change application rates, so do not treat 2,500 square feet as universal. The checked seller excludes Maine and Connecticut from this bundle’s sale or shipment. A printed tips sheet does not replace the bag label, soil needs or local rules.
Selected package
32-pound bag plus printed brochure
Analysis
6-4-0
Maker standard coverage
2,500 square feet; local rates may differ
Watch for: Contains phosphate. Seller states no sale/shipment to Maine or Connecticut; confirm destination and current rules before ordering. The checked New offer came from a third-party seller rather than Amazon.com.
Planting new grass: Scotts Turf Builder Starter 21605, 15 pounds
Scotts’ 21605 page and issued label identify 15 pounds, 24-25-4 analysis and 5,000 square feet of coverage. The maker describes use when starting or reseeding a lawn or installing sod, sprigs or plugs. Choose it for that planting role only when the nutrient analysis and local rules fit.
This starter contains phosphate; new grass alone does not establish that your soil needs it. The label includes water/runoff precautions and says to keep it out of children’s reach. Do not substitute the separate starter-with-weed-control product or repeat growth-percentage marketing as a result for your lawn.
Product / bag
21605 /15 pounds
Analysis
24-25-4
Labeled coverage
5,000 square feet
Watch for: Check soil recommendations and phosphate restrictions before selecting a starter. Follow the current label and new-grass care directions.
Published details from the named brands; confirm the exact variant before ordering.
Pick
Choose it for
Check first
Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Food 22305, 12.5 pounds
Zero-phosphate analysis for established lawns
Read the current bag label, local timing/rate limits and soil recommendations. No burn-free, weed-killing or greening result is promised.
Milorganite 6-4-0, 32-Pound Brochure Bundle
Slow-release nitrogen alternative
Contains phosphate. Seller states no sale/shipment to Maine or Connecticut; confirm destination and current rules before ordering. The checked New offer came from a third-party seller rather than Amazon.com.
Scotts Turf Builder Starter 21605, 15 pounds
Planting new grass
Check soil recommendations and phosphate restrictions before selecting a starter. Follow the current label and new-grass care directions.
A starter label does not replace a soil recommendation
The selected analyses differ:32-0-4, 6-4-0 and 24-25-4. Milorganite and the Scotts Starter contain phosphate, while the selected Lawn Food analysis has a zero middle number. Use soil-test or local extension guidance to determine the needed nutrients instead of assuming a starter is right for every new lawn.
Keep coverage, local limits and cleanup together
Standard bag coverage assumes the product’s labeled application rate. Milorganite explicitly notes that local restrictions can require different rates. Read the delivered bag’s current label before use, including water/drain precautions and storage, and keep unused product in its original container out of children’s reach.
Questions
Will these fertilizer picks also kill weeds?
No weed-control result is established for these selections. A different weed-and-feed or weed-prevention product has its own label and restrictions.
Can I use the 2,500-square-foot Milorganite rate everywhere?
No. Milorganite says local restrictions can change rates. Check the current bag label and rules for your location before use.
Scotts Lawn Food (scotts.com) — 22305 analysis, bag coverage and issued label checked.
Milorganite products (milorganite.com) — Guaranteed analysis and standard 32-pound coverage.
Milorganite use and origin (milorganite.com) — Source material and explicit state/local-rate cautions.
Scotts Starter 21605 (scotts.com) — 15-pound 24-25-4 starter and issued label; does not replace current delivered label.
Listing details and availability can change. Our recommendations are built from the makers' published specs and manuals. Checked offers included sellers other than Amazon.com. Recheck the selected variant, seller and stock status before ordering.