For most lawns, get the Great States 815-18. It cuts 18 in. wide, sets from ½ to 2¾ in. and rolls on 10 in. wheels with a ball-bearing reel. For a bigger lawn, get the Scotts 2000-20S at 20 in. For Bermuda or Zoysia, get the 7-blade Earthwise 1715-16EW.
Best for most lawns$116.00 at AmazonPrice as of Nov 16, 2026, 5:34 AM EST · low stock then
All five were new, sold by Amazon.com and in stock at our 2:22 AM check on Oct 22. Specs come from the maker’s own store pages and the Amazon listings.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
How the five picks score
One formula for all five: cutting width, highest cut, lowest cut, wheel size and a ball-bearing reel.
Plain Buy Guides spec score out of 10, from five checks on published specs. It’s our arithmetic, not a customer rating; the method box lists every input.
The top four sit within two tenths of each other. All have 10 in. wheels and a ball-bearing reel, so width and height range decide the order.
The American Lawn Mower 1304-14 scores 7.6 because it’s the narrowest, with the shortest height range and no ball bearings named. Its 14 in. width is the point for a small yard.
18 in. cut5 blades½–2¾ in. height10 in. wheelsLoop handleModel 815-18
Buy it if
You have an average lawn of cool-season grass and want one mower that cuts short in spring and taller in summer.
Skip it if
Your lawn is big enough that every pass counts. The Scotts 2000-20S cuts 2 in. wider.
The 815-18 is Great States’ 18-inch manual reel mower, made by American Lawn Mower Co. It was new, sold by Amazon.com and in stock at our 2:22 AM check on Oct 22.
It ties for the top score at 9.6, and it’s our pick for most lawns because of its height range. It sets from ½ in. to 2¾ in., the widest range among our picks. That covers a short spring cut and a taller summer cut with one mower.
The reel has five blades. American Lawn Mower’s own advice is that 4 or 5 blades give a great cut on most yards and grasses, and that 5 blades suit thicker lawns because the 10 in. wheels spin the reel well.
Those wheels are 10 in. across, and the maker’s page calls them ball-bearing wheels. The Amazon listing also names a 5-blade ball-bearing reel, so it scores 10 on both checks.
The cutting width is 18 in., which scores 9. By our arithmetic, it takes 34 passes to cross a lawn 50 ft wide, against 30 for the 20 in. Scotts.
The handle is a loop style with cushioned grips, and Great States says the powder-coated finish lasts longer and prevents rust. The blades are heat-treated, which the maker says keeps them sharp longer.
The listing says it assembles without special tools. American Lawn Mower’s FAQ says assembly should take under 10 minutes after reading the manual.
There’s no grass catcher in the box. American Lawn Mower’s GC91820 catcher is listed on Amazon for 18 and 20 in. reels. Neither the maker’s page nor the listing gives a weight or a warranty term.
Our call: the reel mower for most lawns, unless yours is big enough to want 20 in.
20 in. cut5 blades1–3 in. height10 in. + 6 in. wheelsLoop handleModel 2000-20S
Buy it if
Your lawn is on the larger side for a reel mower and you’d rather make fewer passes.
Skip it if
You keep Bermuda or Zoysia under 1 in. The Earthwise sets down to ½ in. with seven blades.
The 2000-20S is Scotts’ classic 20-inch push reel mower, made by American Lawn Mower Co. It was new, sold by Amazon.com and in stock at our 2:22 AM check on Oct 22.
It’s the widest pick. Scotts says the 20 in. cutting width compares to a power mower. By our arithmetic, it crosses a lawn 50 ft wide in 30 passes, four fewer than the 18 in. picks and 13 fewer than the 14 in. American.
The height range is 1 in. to 3 in., set with 9-position QuickSnap adjusters. That’s the highest top setting among our picks, along with the Scotts 716-18S. It scores 10 on the highest-cut check and 8 on the lowest.
The reel has five blades on five spiders and runs on ball bearings, by the maker’s description. The blades are heat-treated steel.
The wheels are what set it apart. Two 10 in. composite wheels with radial tread do the driving, and 6 in. rear tracking wheels behind them help it run straight. Scotts says the rear wheel design reduces drag and improves maneuvering.
A welded reel hood protects plants and shrubs that hang over the edge of the lawn. The loop handle has a foam grip, and the listing says assembly needs no tools.
The maker lists its size as 28 × 18 × 11 in. but gives no weight. There’s no grass catcher in the box, and the maker’s page lists the mower, handle and composite wheels as what’s included.
Its blades get the same five-blade advice as the Great States. American Lawn Mower’s FAQ says 5-blade reels suit thicker lawns because the 10 in. wheels spin the reel well, and that 4 or 5 blades give a great cut on most yards.
It ties the Great States at 9.6. Our call: the reel mower for a lawn that’s bigger than most reel owners mow.
Maker advises 4 or 5 blades for fescue and bluegrass
No warranty term published
16 in. cut7 blades½–2½ in. height10 in. wheelsT-handleModel 1715-16EW
Buy it if
Your lawn is Bermuda, Zoysia, centipede or St. Augustine and you like it kept short and even.
Skip it if
Your lawn is fescue, bluegrass or rye. The maker itself recommends a 4 or 5-blade reel like the Great States.
The 1715-16EW is Earthwise’s 16-inch manual reel with seven blades, made by American Lawn Mower Co. It was new, sold by Amazon.com and in stock at our 2:22 AM check on Oct 22.
The maker built it for bent grass. Its page names Bermuda, Zoysia, centipede, St. Augustine and Seashore paspalum, the warm-season grasses that creep along the ground. That’s why it’s labeled for Bermuda and Zoysia.
The same page is just as clear about what it’s not for. For taller, wetter upright grasses like fescue, bluegrass, rye and mixed weeds, it recommends a 4 or 5-blade reel instead.
American Lawn Mower’s FAQ says seven blades give the reel more momentum, suit creeping grass and a very short cut, and give the most even cut of its reels.
The height range is ½ in. to 2½ in. The ½ in. bottom setting scores 10 and suits grasses kept short. The 2½ in. top setting scores 9, a step below the 3 in. Scotts models.
The cutting width is 16 in., which scores 8. It takes 38 passes to cross a 50 ft lawn by our arithmetic.
Earthwise lists unbreakable steel side plates and a tempered alloy steel reel and bed knife. The bed knife is the fixed blade the reel cuts against, like the second half of a pair of scissors. The wheels are 10 in. composite, and the reel runs on ball bearings.
Amazon also lists it in a bundle with American Lawn Mower’s SK-2 hand sharpener. The maker’s FAQ says factory-sharpened blades may need sharpening after several years.
It scores 9.4. Our call: the mower for a warm-season lawn kept short, and the wrong one for a fescue lawn.
18 in. cut7 blades1–3 in. height10 in. + 6 in. wheelsLoop handleModel 716-18S
Buy it if
You want a 7-blade reel’s even cut on a warm-season lawn kept around 1 to 3 in., with wider passes than the Earthwise.
Skip it if
You keep your grass under 1 in. The Earthwise sets down to ½ in.
The 716-18S is the Scotts 18-inch 7-blade Pro reel mower, made by American Lawn Mower Co. It was new, sold by Amazon.com and in stock at our 2:22 AM check on Oct 22.
It’s the only pick that pairs seven blades with a 3 in. top setting. Its height range is 1 in. to 3 in., the same as the Scotts 2000-20S. The Earthwise, the other 7-blade pick, stops at 2½ in. but goes lower.
The reel has four spiders carrying seven blades on ball bearings. The spiders are the round frames inside the reel that hold the blades in their spiral.
American Lawn Mower’s FAQ says 7-blade reels suit thicker lawns on 10 in. wheels, suit creeping grass and give the most even cut. Its Earthwise page adds that 4 or 5 blades are better for taller, wetter upright grasses like fescue and bluegrass.
The cutting width is 18 in., which scores 9, the same as the Great States. It takes 34 passes to cross a 50 ft lawn by our arithmetic, four more than the 20 in. Scotts.
Like the 2000-20S, it has dual wheel tracking: 10 in. composite wheels at the front and 6 in. tracking wheels at the back. The handle is a cushioned loop style, and Scotts lists tool-less assembly.
The listing says the blades are heat-treated alloy steel that stays sharp longer. Neither the maker’s page nor the listing gives a weight or a warranty term.
It loses points only on its 1 in. lowest setting. For a Bermuda lawn kept at ½ in., that setting is the deciding difference, and the Earthwise wins.
It scores 9.4. Our call: a 7-blade mower for a warm-season lawn you keep a little taller, or for anyone who wants the most even cut at 18 in. wide.
14 in. cut5 blades1–2¼ in. height10 in. wheelsT-handleModel 1304-14
Buy it if
Your lawn is a small patch, a strip beside a drive or a yard with tight gates and corners.
Skip it if
Your lawn is average or larger. At 43 passes across a 50 ft lawn, the Great States needs 9 fewer.
The 1304-14 is American Lawn Mower Co.’s own-name 14-inch reel with five blades. It was new, sold by Amazon.com and in stock at our 2:22 AM check on Oct 22.
It’s here for size. At 14 in., it’s the narrowest pick, which makes it easy to steer through a gate or around beds on a small lawn. That’s why it’s labeled for a small lawn.
The narrow cut has a cost. By our arithmetic, it takes 43 passes to cross a lawn 50 ft wide, against 30 for the Scotts 2000-20S. On a small yard, those extra passes are short ones.
Specs come from the Amazon listing, because the maker’s page for this model carries only its general reel mower text. The listing gives a 5-blade reel, 10 in. polymer wheels and an adjustable height of 1 in. to 2¼ in.
That range is the shortest among our picks, scoring 8 on both height checks. The listing says it can cut grass up to 4 in. tall, which matches the maker’s FAQ for dry grass.
Neither source names ball bearings in the reel, so under our house rule that check scores 5. That’s the main reason it scores 7.6, the lowest here and still above our 7.0 floor.
The blades are heat-treated alloy steel that the listing says stays sharp for years. The handle is a T-style, as the product photo shows. A 1304-14GC version with a grass catcher was only offered used at our check. The listing calls the mower lightweight and low maintenance but gives no weight. American Lawn Mower’s FAQ puts its reel mowers at 19 to 39 lb, depending on size.
Our call: the reel mower for a small lawn where a narrow cut and a light push matter more than speed.
The five picks compared
From American Lawn Mower Co.’s store pages and the Amazon listings. Scroll sideways on a phone; tap a number heading to sort on a desktop.
All five are manual push reel mowers: no engine, no battery, no cord. The reel spins only as you push, and it cuts against a fixed bed knife like scissors.
One company makes all five
The brands differ. The factory behind them doesn’t.
Brand on the mower
Our picks
Made by
Great States
815-18
American Lawn Mower Co.
Scotts
2000-20S, 716-18S
American Lawn Mower Co.
Earthwise
1715-16EW
American Lawn Mower Co. (sold as Earthwise Power Tools by ALM)
American Lawn Mower
1304-14
American Lawn Mower Co.
American Lawn Mower Co. sells all four brands on its own store and lists every one of them on its warranty request form. It also lists Black+Decker, Craftsman and Hyper Tough reel mowers there.
The company says it has made reel mowers since 1895 and calls itself the nation’s largest maker of them.
That changes how to shop. Two mowers with different names can share most of their parts, so compare model numbers and specs, not labels.
The Great States 815-18 and American Lawn Mower 1815-18, for example, list the same 18 in. width, five blades and ½ to 2¾ in. range.
4, 5 or 7 blades: match the reel to your grass
More blades isn’t always better. The maker’s own advice depends on what grows in your yard.
Blades
Maker’s advice
Grass it suits
Our picks
4
Best on lighter yards; may get bogged down on very heavy, thick lawns
Light, thin lawns
None (the 1204-14 is left out)
5
Best on thicker lawns; with 10 in. wheels the reel spins well
Most yards: fescue, bluegrass, rye, mixed weeds
Great States 815-18, Scotts 2000-20S, ALM 1304-14
7
Also for thicker lawns; more momentum, best for creeping grass and a very short cut, most even cut
Bermuda, Zoysia, centipede, St. Augustine, seashore paspalum
Earthwise 1715-16EW, Scotts 716-18S
American Lawn Mower’s FAQ says that for most yards and grasses, 4 or 5 blades give a great cut. Its Earthwise page says 7-blade reels are most efficient on bent grass and recommends 4 or 5 blades for taller, wetter upright grasses.
So if you don’t know your grass, start with five blades. If your lawn spreads by runners across the ground and you keep it short, seven blades fit better.
Our suggestion: pull up a few blades and look at how they grow before you choose.
How low and how high each one cuts
Reel mowers cut shorter than most rotary mowers, but each has a different top setting.
Each bar runs from the lowest to the highest setting. From the maker’s store pages, or the listing for the 1304-14.
Pick
Lowest
Highest
How it’s set
Great States 815-18
½ in.
2¾ in.
Adjustable
Scotts 2000-20S
1 in.
3 in.
9 QuickSnap positions
Earthwise 1715-16EW
½ in.
2½ in.
Adjustable
Scotts 716-18S
1 in.
3 in.
Adjustable
American Lawn Mower 1304-14
1 in.
2¼ in.
Adjustable
American Lawn Mower’s FAQ says height is set in two ways: move the roller or trailing wheels up and down, or move the reel higher or lower on the wheels. Depending on the model, there are 9 to 36 settings. The owner’s manual shows how for each one.
A low setting suits warm-season grass kept short. A high setting suits cool-season grass in summer heat. If you want both, the Great States covers the widest span, from ½ to 2¾ in.
How many passes your lawn takes
Cutting width decides how many trips across the lawn you make.
Our arithmetic: 600 in. divided by the cutting width, rounded up, with no overlap. Real mowing overlaps each pass a little, so expect a few more.
Going from 14 in. to 20 in. cuts the passes by almost a third, 43 down to 30. Those saved trips add up on a bigger lawn mowed every week.
A wider reel also means more blade to push through the grass at once, which is why American Lawn Mower’s FAQ suggests cutting half the width at a time when the grass is tall.
Your lawn
Width to look at
Picks
Small patch, strips, tight gates
14 in.
American Lawn Mower 1304-14
Typical back or front yard
16 to 18 in.
Great States 815-18, Earthwise 1715-16EW, Scotts 716-18S
Larger yard you still want to push
20 in.
Scotts 2000-20S
Reel mower strengths and limits
The maker’s own FAQ is frank about the limits. Here they are in one place.
Situation
What the maker says
What to do
Dry grass up to 4 in.
Most dry grasses can be cut even at 4 in. high
Mow as usual
Wet or drooping grass
Reels have difficulty; they work best on dry grass that stands up
Wait until it dries
Grass that grew tall
Hard to push across the full width
Cut half the reel width at a time over short stretches, or raise the height and cut twice
Some blades left standing
Blades the reel doesn’t catch aren’t cut; a second pass may be needed
Go over them again; the maker says the lawn evens out over time
Mowing schedule
Cut before the grass is more than an inch taller than last time
Mow on that schedule, more often in fast-growing weeks
Clippings
They break down and feed the lawn, like any mower’s
No need to rake
American Lawn Mower compares a reel mower to a pair of scissors and a rotary mower to a fast blade that chops the top off the grass. The reel pulls a little grass into the cutter bar as you walk.
The maker says to push at a good walking speed, not slowly.
A reel mower suits a small to average lawn that you mow often. It isn’t a good fit for a lawn you let grow tall between cuts, or one full of twigs. Our suggestion: pick up sticks before you mow, since the reel works by pulling what it meets into the cutter bar.
Manual, electric or gas reel mowers
Reel mowers come in three kinds. This guide scores the manual kind only.
Kind
What drives the reel
An example we checked
In this guide
Manual push reel
Your pushing, through the wheels
All five picks
Yes, scored
Electric reel
A battery and motor
Sun Joe 24V-CRLM15 cordless reel
No, a different kind
Gas reel
A small engine
California Trimmer power reel
No, a different kind
We score one kind at a time so one formula is fair. A battery reel would need checks for run time and charging, and a gas reel for the engine. For powered rotary mowers, see our electric lawn mower guide.
Reel mowers we checked and left out
Popular names we looked at and didn’t pick, and why.
Reel mower
Why it isn’t a pick
What it does well
Fiskars StaySharp Max
Only offered by Amazon Germany with a 10-week lead time at our check
A well-known name with 2,400 searches a month
American Lawn Mower 1815-18
Same listed specs as the Great States 815-18, under the maker’s own name
Listing mentions a 5-year protection plan
American Lawn Mower 1204-14
Scores 7.4: 8½ in. wheels and a top setting under 2 in. (the maker’s page gives both 1½ and 1¾ in.)
19 lb, the lightest weight the maker gives
LawnMaster LMRM1801
We didn’t check it against LawnMaster’s own documents, which we need before a pick
Includes a collection bag
Sun Joe MJ manual reels
Sold by Spreetail and JOE Authorized, not Amazon.com
Some include a grass catcher
Scotts 415-16S Elite
Only offered used at our check
16 in. Scotts reel
Fiskars is the name many people search for, but the only offer at our check was from Amazon Germany with a 10-week wait. We prefer mowers sold by Amazon.com or the maker and in stock now. We’ll look again at the next update.
Keeping a reel mower cutting
Reel mowers need little care, but the care they need is specific. All of this is from the maker’s FAQ.
Job
What the maker says
Cleaning
Use a leaf blower or brush, not a hose, to prevent rust; a damp cloth for buildup before storage
Stiff to push
Surface rust can form on the blades and cutting bar; a light coat of WD-40 loosens the cutting action
Winter storage
Clean it, then rub wax (a household candle works) along each blade and the cutting bar; it comes off when you mow in spring
Bearings
Should not need grease, even after many years
Checking the cut
The blades should cut paper all the way across the cutter bar
Not cutting at all
The cutting bar has likely been knocked out of line; realign it using the owner’s manual
Dull after years
Sharpen with a kit; American Lawn Mower sells the SK-1 and SK-2
The paper test is the one to remember. Slide a strip of paper between the reel and the bed knife and turn the reel by hand. A mower in good adjustment snips it cleanly all the way across.
Our suggestion: do the test each spring before the first cut.
Answer these in order. The first yes is usually your pick.
Question
If yes
If no
Is your lawn Bermuda, Zoysia or another creeping grass kept short?
Earthwise 1715-16EW
Read on
Do you want seven blades but cut up to 3 in.?
Scotts 716-18S
Read on
Is your lawn larger than a typical yard?
Scotts 2000-20S, 20 in.
Read on
Is it a small patch with tight gates or beds?
American Lawn Mower 1304-14, 14 in.
Read on
None of the above?
Great States 815-18
Great States 815-18
Grass type first, then lawn size. Those two settle almost every choice. After that, the height range decides between close picks.
Moving clippings or soil around the yard? Our garden cart guide compares carts.
Questions people ask
What is the best reel mower?
For most lawns, the Great States 815-18: 18 in. wide, ½ to 2¾ in. cutting height, 10 in. wheels and a ball-bearing reel. For a bigger lawn, the Scotts 2000-20S at 20 in. For Bermuda or Zoysia, the 7-blade Earthwise 1715-16EW.
Are reel mowers worth it?
For a small to average lawn of dry, upright grass that you mow often, a reel mower cuts like scissors with no fuel or charging. It struggles with wet, drooping or overgrown grass, by the maker’s own FAQ.
How tall can grass be for a reel mower?
American Lawn Mower’s FAQ says most dry grasses can be cut even at 4 in. high. It recommends mowing before the grass is more than an inch taller than the last cut.
Should I get a 5-blade or 7-blade reel mower?
Five blades for most yards, including fescue, bluegrass and rye. Seven blades for creeping warm-season grasses like Bermuda and Zoysia kept short, by the maker’s advice.
Who makes Scotts reel mowers?
American Lawn Mower Co. It also makes the Great States and Earthwise reel mowers and sells all of them on its own store.
How much does a reel mower weigh?
American Lawn Mower says its reel mowers weigh 19 to 39 lb depending on size. The 14 in. 1204-14 is 19 lb. The makers don’t publish weights for our five picks.
Can a reel mower cut wet grass?
Not well. The maker says reels work best when the grass is dry and standing up. Wait for it to dry.
Why does my reel mower leave some grass uncut?
Blades the reel doesn’t catch aren’t pulled into the cutter bar. The maker says a second pass may be needed, and that a lawn evens out after several cuts with a reel.
Do reel mowers need sharpening?
The blades are sharpened at the factory. After several years they may need it; American Lawn Mower sells the SK-1 and SK-2 sharpening kits.
How do I store a reel mower for winter?
Clean off the clippings, then rub wax, such as a candle, along each blade and the cutting bar. The wax keeps moisture off and wears away when you mow in spring.
Do I need to rake clippings after a reel mower?
No. The maker says clippings break down and add nutrients back into the lawn, as with any mower.
Is a reel mower hard to assemble?
American Lawn Mower says assembly needs no tools and should take under 10 minutes after reading the owner’s manual.
How we pick reel mowers
How we pick
We looked for manual push reel mowers whose maker or Amazon listing publishes cutting width, height range, blade count and wheel size. We kept five that score 7.0 or more on one formula.
At 2:22 AM on Oct 22, 2026, the Amazon listings showed each pick new, in stock and sold by Amazon.com.
Why trust us
Isaac Daniels owns and edits Plain Buy Guides. The specs, blade advice and care steps on this page come from American Lawn Mower Co.’s own store pages and reel mower FAQ, with the Amazon listings where the maker’s page is silent. The pass counts are worked out in the open. Each source is named below.
The spec score, check by check
Each check scores 0 to 10 from published specs and counts one fifth of the total. A mower needs 7.0 to be picked. A fact neither the maker nor the listing states scores 5. It’s our score, not a customer rating, and no maker publishes a warranty term we could score.
Check (weight)
How it’s scored
Cutting width (1/5)
10 for 20 in. or more; 9 for 18 to 19 in.; 8 for 16 to 17 in.; 7 for 14 to 15 in.
Highest cut (1/5)
10 for 3 in. or more; 9 for 2½ in. or more; 8 for 2 in. or more; 7 below 2 in.
Lowest cut (1/5)
10 for ½ in. or less; 8 for up to 1 in.; 7 above 1 in.
Wheels (1/5)
10 for 10 in. or more; 8 for 8½ to 9.9 in.; 7 below 8½ in.
Ball-bearing reel (1/5)
10 when the maker or listing names ball bearings in the reel or wheels; 5 when neither does
Total
Average of the five, to one decimal
Reel mower
Cutting width
Highest cut
Lowest cut
Wheels
Ball-bearing reel
Score
Great States 815-18
9
9
10
10
10
9.6
Scotts 2000-20S
10
10
8
10
10
9.6
Earthwise 1715-16EW
8
9
10
10
10
9.4
Scotts 716-18S
9
10
8
10
10
9.4
American Lawn Mower 1304-14
7
8
8
10
5
7.6
ALM 1204-14 (left out)
7
7
10
8
5
7.4
Sources
American Lawn Mower Co., store pages for the Great States 815-18, Scotts 2000-20S, Earthwise 1715-16EW, Scotts 716-18S, American Lawn Mower 1304-14, 1815-18 and 1204-14, read Oct 22, 2026
American Lawn Mower Co., Reel Mower FAQ’s page, read Oct 22, 2026
American Lawn Mower Co., warranty request form (model list), read Oct 22, 2026
Amazon listings for the five picks and for the Fiskars StaySharp Max, LawnMaster LMRM1801, Sun Joe MJ500M, MJ503M and MJ504M, and Scotts 415-16S, read Oct 22, 2026
Amazon offer and image reads, Oct 22, 2026, 2:22 AM EDT