American Tourister Belle Voyage Softside Carry-On Spinner (92427-1041, Black) vs Samsonite Framelock Max Carry-On Spinner (149618-5423, Glacial Silver)
These are side-by-side facts taken from each product guide: published specifications, strengths and caveats as their sources state them. This page is not a test, a ranking or a verdict about which model is better.
American Tourister Belle Voyage Softside Carry-On Spinner (92427-1041, Black)
A softside carry-on with blouse and shoe pockets where 23.5 inches is allowed
Belle Voyage is a 7.8-pound polyester spinner with 1.5 inches of expansion and door-panel pockets for a blouse and shoes. American Tourister measures it at 23.5 inches tall, not the 21 inches in the Amazon title, and neither source describes a case lock.
Published specifications
- Exterior 23.5 x 14.5 x 10.2 in; linear 48.2 in (maker)
- Interior 20.3 x 14 x 8 in
- Weight 7.8 lb; polyester softside
- Expands 1.5 inches
- Single airflow spinner wheels; push-button locking handle
- Limited 10 Year Global Warranty (defects only)
Strengths
- Blouse and shoe pockets on the door panel plus a modesty pocket
- 1.5-inch expansion for extra packing space
- Dimensions and weight match between maker and listing
Caveats
- 23.5-inch height contradicts the 21-inch label in the listing title
- No built-in case lock described by either source
- Black colour not shown on American Tourister's own site
Read the full American Tourister Belle Voyage Softside Carry-On Spinner (92427-1041, Black) guide
Samsonite Framelock Max Carry-On Spinner (149618-5423, Glacial Silver)
A zipper-less frame carry-on with keyless one-slide locking
Framelock Max replaces the zipper with a frame closure and a single Eazylock slide that locks several points with keyless TSA-approved security. At 21.5 x 15.4 x 8.8 inches it is compact, but neither Samsonite nor the listing states any expansion.
Published specifications
- Exterior 21.5 x 15.4 x 8.8 in; linear 45.6 in (maker)
- Interior 19.7 x 14.1 x 8.6 in
- Weight 7.2 lb (spec) or 7.32 lb (feature list)
- Zipper-less frame; Eazylock keyless TSA lock
- Polycarbonate shell per Samsonite
- Limited 10 Year Global Warranty (defects only)
Strengths
- Zipper-less frame closes with one centralised slide and multi-point lock
- Compact 21.5 x 15.4 x 8.8 in exterior
- Multiple interior zipper dividers with pockets
Caveats
- No expansion stated by Samsonite or the listing
- Amazon's table lists polypropylene; Samsonite says polycarbonate
- No exterior pocket or laptop sleeve described
Read the full Samsonite Framelock Max Carry-On Spinner (149618-5423, Glacial Silver) guide
How to choose between them
Choose the American Tourister Belle Voyage Softside Carry-On Spinner (92427-1041, Black) if your situation matches: A softside carry-on with blouse and shoe pockets where 23.5 inches is allowed. Its main caveat: 23.5-inch height contradicts the 21-inch label in the listing title.
Choose the Samsonite Framelock Max Carry-On Spinner (149618-5423, Glacial Silver) if your situation matches: A zipper-less frame carry-on with keyless one-slide locking. Its main caveat: No expansion stated by Samsonite or the listing.
Both entries repeat what each guide records. Confirm the model, included parts and availability on the current listing before ordering.
Primary sources
- American Tourister Belle Voyage Softside Carry-On page and specifications (item 924271094, 92427 family) Source for American Tourister Belle Voyage Softside Carry-On Spinner (92427-1041, Black)
- American Tourister warranty page: Limited 10 Year Global Warranty terms Source for American Tourister Belle Voyage Softside Carry-On Spinner (92427-1041, Black)
- Samsonite Framelock Max Carry-On Spinner page and specifications (item 149618) Source for Samsonite Framelock Max Carry-On Spinner (149618-5423, Glacial Silver)
- Samsonite warranty page: Limited 10 Year Global Warranty terms Source for Samsonite Framelock Max Carry-On Spinner (149618-5423, Glacial Silver)
Primary sources checked .