Dogtra GPS Fence Virtual Fence Collar vs PetSafe Guardian GPS 2.0 Dog Fence + Tracking (PIF00-18096)
These are side-by-side facts taken from each product guide: published specifications, strengths and caveats as their sources state them. This page is not a test, a ranking or a verdict about which model is better.
Check Dogtra GPS Fence Virtual Fence Collar on AmazonCheck PetSafe Guardian GPS 2.0 Dog Fence + Tracking (PIF00-18096) on Amazon
Dogtra GPS Fence Virtual Fence Collar
Owners of open outdoor properties of at least 3/4 acre who want containment without a subscription
The Dogtra GPS Fence is a virtual containment collar: you draw up to 30 boundaries in the app, and the collar enforces a warning zone, a primary fence and two backup fences without a phone connection or monthly fee. It needs at least 3/4 acre outdoors and has no live tracking. Dogtra gives both 15 and 10 pounds as the minimum dog weight.
Published specifications
- Maker: warning zone, primary fence and two backup fences; up to 30 fences
- Maker: 3/4 acre minimum; outdoor use only; remove collar indoors
- Maker: circular fence 13 yd to 2.5 mi across; custom fence up to 25 posts
- Maker: 7 x 1.63 x 1.42 in, 6.9 oz; 3/4 x 32 in strap; 10 in minimum neck
- Maker: lithium polymer battery; 2-hour first charge; IPX9K
- Maker: iOS 14 or Android 7.0 with Bluetooth 5.0; 1-year warranty
Strengths
- No monthly fee, and the collar works without a phone after setup
- Layered warning zone plus two backup fences beyond the main boundary
- Custom-shaped or circular fences, up to 30 saved
Caveats
- No live tracking or notifications; containment only
- Needs at least 3/4 acre with a clear view of the sky
- Dogtra states the minimum dog weight as 15 lb and as 10 lb
PetSafe Guardian GPS 2.0 Dog Fence + Tracking (PIF00-18096)
Owners of open yards of 1/2 acre or more who want both a virtual fence and live tracking
The Guardian GPS 2.0 combines a virtual fence with real-time tracking on a rechargeable collar that PetSafe rates at up to 70 hours per charge. It stores up to 50 boundaries and offers tone, vibration and 10 static levels. It needs a subscription for each dog, 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi for setup and cellular service, and PetSafe's own boundary rules set post distances from buildings and roads.
Published specifications
- Maker: up to 50 custom boundaries; tracking-only mode available
- Maker: 1/2 acre or larger, without dense tree coverage
- Maker: posts 25 ft per story from buildings, 15 ft from roads
- Maker: neck from 8 in; dogs 10 lb and up; about 6 months or older
- Maker: rechargeable, up to 70 hours; magnetic charging base
- Maker: subscription per dog; 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi and cellular required
Strengths
- Fence and real-time tracking in one collar, with a tracking-only mode
- Up to 50 saved boundaries
- PetSafe publishes clear boundary-distance rules in the user guide
Caveats
- Subscription required for every dog, on top of a collar per dog
- Needs 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi for setup and cellular service to work
- Guide warns app notifications can be delayed or missed
Read the full PetSafe Guardian GPS 2.0 Dog Fence + Tracking (PIF00-18096) guide
How to choose between them
Choose the Dogtra GPS Fence Virtual Fence Collar if your situation matches: Owners of open outdoor properties of at least 3/4 acre who want containment without a subscription. Its main caveat: No live tracking or notifications; containment only.
Choose the PetSafe Guardian GPS 2.0 Dog Fence + Tracking (PIF00-18096) if your situation matches: Owners of open yards of 1/2 acre or more who want both a virtual fence and live tracking. Its main caveat: Subscription required for every dog, on top of a collar per dog.
Both entries repeat what each guide records. Confirm the model, included parts and availability on the current listing before ordering.
Primary sources
- Dogtra product page for the DOGTRA GPS FENCE Source for Dogtra GPS Fence Virtual Fence Collar
- Dogtra GPS Fence Owner's Manual supplied with the listing Source for Dogtra GPS Fence Virtual Fence Collar
- PetSafe product page for Guardian GPS 2.0 Dog Fence + Tracking (PIF00-18096) Source for PetSafe Guardian GPS 2.0 Dog Fence + Tracking (PIF00-18096)
- PetSafe Guardian GPS 2.0 Dog Fence + Tracking User Guide supplied with the listing Source for PetSafe Guardian GPS 2.0 Dog Fence + Tracking (PIF00-18096)
Primary sources checked .